Newspaper Page Text
4D Sunday, November 25, 2018
The Times, Gainesville, Georgia | gainesvilletimes.com
VIEWPOINT
Trump flipping on immigration makes for a wild ride
This time of year,
President Trump should be
thankful for the immigra
tion debate.
It is a distraction that
steals the public’s attention
away from administration
flubs, GOP election losses
and policy failures. It’s
a tool to fire up his base,
especially those folks who
say they care about the rule
of law but really worry that
America is becoming too
brownish. And it’s a way to
oversimplify a complicated
issue that revolves around
supply and demand as
well as a need to balance
workforce demands with
legitimate concerns about
whether foreigners are
properly assimilating.
If you’re a president who
doesn’t mind breaking apart
society and dividing the
American people for your
own benefit, the immigra
tion debate can be incred
ibly useful. But it must be
handled with care.
The issue often slips away
from Trump. Promises get
broken. Lies get told. Initia
tives are reversed. There is
backtracking and double-
talk. The White House will
RUBEN NAVARRETTE
ruben@rubennavarrette.com
get everyone all worked up,
and then say: “Oh, never
mind.”
Indeed, if all the policy
discussions were attractions
in an amusement park,
immigration would be “Mr.
Trump’s Wild Ride.”
Here are some recent
twists and turns:
■ Trump promised a
“big beautiful wall” on
the U.S.-Mexico border
that would keep out illegal
immigrants and illegal
drugs. But he misled his
supporters into thinking
that Mexico would pay for
it. When Mexico took a hard
pass, the wall got downsized
to barbed wire and fence
repairs. Last week, during a
visit to the border near San
Diego, Homeland Security
Secretary Kirstjen Nielsen
— who you’d think would
have empathy for people
looking for work since,
according to media reports,
she could soon be without a
job herself — proudly sur
veyed the metal structures
and declared her mission
accomplished.
■ Trump said early in
his presidential campaign
that any wall that his
administration built would
have a wide “door” to let
immigrants come in legally.
And, in recent weeks, he has
repeatedly made the case
that America welcomes
legal immigration as a way
to fill vacant jobs. Yet, by
any measure, this adminis
tration has been extremely
hostile to legal immigra
tion. It pursues policies that
would whittle it down to
dangerously low levels, and
punishes legal immigrants
who have been forced to
rely on public-assistance
programs that they paid for
with their taxes.
■ Trump tried to gin up
votes for Republicans in the
midterm elections by mak
ing a big spectacle of dis
patching 5,800 U.S. troops
to the border. Supposedly,
TOY
■ Continued from 1D
Both he and Kimberly
Mosley, president of the
Chicago-based American
Specialty Toy Retailing
Association, expect a post
holiday shakeout.
Retailers that are new to
the business might struggle if
they can’t convince consum
ers to think of them as desti
nations for toys or if they’re
unable to offer the expertise
and selection of dedicated
toy stores, Mosley said.
“We don’t expect they’ll
want to stay if they’re not
successful,” she said.
In the meantime, inde
pendent toy store owners
said they’re leaning into
strategies they were already
using to fend off competition
from Toys R Us, other big-
box chains and Amazon, like
carrying more unusual toys
parents might not find in a
bigger retailer’s toy aisle,
providing extra services like
free gift wrapping, or advis
ing shoppers on toys that
would fit a child’s age and
interests.
“If you came into the
store and said you’re shop
ping for your 3-year-old
nephew, we’re not going
to let you buy a 1,000-piece
puzzle,” Building Blocks’
Nguyen said.
Megan Morrison, 61, of
Highland Park, said she
likes buying gifts for her
three grandchildren at
Beanstalk because the store
will deliver toys already
assembled, sparing parents
the headache.
Beanstalk also will hang
on to gifts and drop them off
the day before Christmas or
Hanukkah to help parents
thwart impatient kids who
like to snoop, Hillman said.
Even parents who buy
toys online and at big-box
stores said they liked having
a local option too.
The Gruby family has
bought toys at Toys R Us,
Amazon and Target, but
Benjamin, 6, likes the
built-in entertainment at
Beanstalk. He tried out the
store’s whack-a-mole, darts
and basketball games on
Monday while he and his
dad waited for his mom.
Target and Amazon seem
to sell many of the same
things Toys R Us did, but
Beanstalk has more spe
cialty toys and employees
who “can help with what’s
trendy,” said Michael
Gruby, 39.
If nothing else, most indus
try watchers say consumer
spending has been healthy
and shoppers appear ready
to buy this holiday season.
Both Nguyen and Hillman
are optimistic enough to
take on extra space. Build
ing Blocks recently opened
a third location in Chicago’s
Lincoln Park area.
Hillman took over a
store on the same block as
Beanstalk and her two kids’
clothing shops. For the time
being, it’s filled with over
size items that look impres
sive under a tree but didn’t
fit in jam-packed Beanstalk,
like toy kitchens, foosball
tables, child-size taco and
ice cream stands and a
Bentley-brand stroller that
converts to a tricycle. After
the holidays, Hillman plans
to replace the toys with baby
and toddler apparel.
Toy manufacturers also
increasingly seem to rec
ognize the importance of
working with smaller stores,
said Rick Derr, who owns
a Learning Express Toys
franchise in Lake Zurich,
Ill. Over the past few years,
he’s been able to get prod
ucts from toymakers that
previously only worked
with larger retailers and get
access to new toys before
they make it to national
chains’ shelves.
Local retailers tend to
have strong relationships
with customers, which
allows them to give manu
facturers immediate feed
back on reaction to a new
product or strategy for pro
moting it, Derr said.
That’s valuable to manu
facturers, who are trying to
react more quickly to what
customers want, The Toy
Association’s Pasierb said.
It’s also in manufacturers’
interest to keep a variety
of toy retailers healthy, he
added.
There’s another reason
Derr is optimistic about
sales this season: Ever since
people began speculating
about whether or not Toys
R Us would make it through
the holiday season last year,
toys have been on consum
ers’ minds. There was news
coverage of the closing sales
and the impact on toymak
ers. More recently, other
retailers have been heavily
promoting items expected to
be popular holiday gifts.
“When toys are in the
news, good or bad, it helps
us,” Derr said. “Our whole
year has been very, very
good.”
MATTHEWS
■ Continued from 3D
universal basic income, free college tuition,
higher taxes on companies and the wealthy,
massive green energy spending and a ramp-
up of regulations on business.
While Sherrod Brown can claim to be a
long-standing member of the Democratic
Party’s progressive wing — coming in 10th
place in GovTrack’s 2017 ranking of the
most liberal senators — he may not be as
radical as the party’s movers and shakers.
Perhaps more importantly, he just seems
like yesterday’s news.
The Republican leadership struggled in
the last presidential election with how to
deal fairly with so many candidates. Demo
crats may face a similar dilemma.
Those who don’t poll well after only a
short period of time should voluntarily
drop out so that a small number of viable
candidates can more effectively share the
limited amount of media attention and cam
paign contributions.
If Sherrod Brown is not a viable candi
date, it will become obvious to most people
fairly quickly. The bigger challenge will
be getting Democratic candidates who are
trailing far behind to accept what the voters
already know.
Merrill Matthews is a resident scholar with
the Institute for Policy Innovation. He holds
a PhD in the Humanities from the University
of Texas. Readers may write him at IPI,
Suite 820,1320 Greenway Drive, Irving, TX,
75038
HERSHEY
■ Continued from 3D
ERAs with the same inten
sity he brings to trade
deficits and unemployment
rates.
A doctor’s son, Brown
has an undergraduate
degree from Yale that
should appeal to the Demo
cratic elite but also has
graduate degrees from
the Ohio State University,
which confirm him as a
real Buckeye.
If he gets in the race,
Brown’s 1986 divorce
could become an issue.
His Republican opponent
this year, U.S. Rep. Jim
Renacci, accused Brown of
domestic violence. Brown’s
wife at the time, however,
denounced the GOP attack
and has hosted fundraisers
for her former husband.
If Brown were to win the
nomination, Trump would
be in an unlikely position
to bring up the divorce. It’s
hard to imagine any of the
women who say they’ve
been mistreated by the
president raising money
for his re-election.
In addition, Brown cur
rently is happily remar
ried to popular syndicated
columnist Connie Schultz.
He may not be an instant
front-runner, but he has
the ability and personality
to streak past the Demo
crats’ current collection of
has-beens.
William Hershey is a former
Washington correspondent
for the Akron Beacon Journal
and a former Columbus
bureau chief for the Akron
Beacon Journal and Dayton
Daily News. He is co-author
of Mr. Chairman The Life
and Times of Ray C. Bliss.
Readers may write him
at 261 W. Schreyer Place,
Columbus, Ohio 43214
they were going to repel an
approaching caravan of an
estimated 8,000 to 10,000
migrants and refugees. The
stunt didn’t work. Voters
chose health care as their
top issue over immigration.
And, as soon as the election
was over, Army Lt. Jeffrey
Buchanan told Politico that
the troops would be heading
home in time for Christmas.
As they leave, the troops
can wave at the caravan,
which has now started
arriving in Tijuana.
■ Finally, remember
when Trump got the nativ-
ist right wing all worked
up over a promise to scrap
the 14th Amendment and
end so-called birthright
citizenship for the U.S.-born
children of undocumented
immigrants? Well, forget
it. That was never a serious
idea. That was just a cruel
tease intended to manipu
late the hardliners. Accord
ing to The Washington Post,
now that the midterms are
done, White House officials
are freely admitting that
Trump has no plans at the
moment to follow through
with an executive order
that would end birthright
citizenship.
Are we having fun yet?
Trump still seems to be hav
ing a blast with his favorite
chew toy: the immigration
issue.
I’m not having fun. It’s
surreal to watch someone
who got so many breaks
in life due to his father’s
money and connections talk
about the importance of
only letting in immigrants
with “merit.” It’s absurd
to see someone who has,
throughout his business
career, cut corners and
violated regulations sud
denly emphasizing the
importance of following the
rules. And it’s ridiculous to
have someone who has — at
various points in his life —
paid little or no taxes, taking
full advantage of existing
loopholes and creating new
ones, accusing others of
“gaming the system.”
Nonetheless, let’s give
Trump credit for know
ing his audience. He has
a Ph.D. in human nature.
He figured out that Ameri
cans — whether in politics,
media or the town square
— just love to talk about
immigration.
Imagine how much better
off this country would be
if they, and the president
whom so many of them sup
port, actually knew what
they were talking about.
Ruben Navarrette writes for
the Washington Post Writers
Group.
SUNDAY CARTOON GALLERY
DANA SUMMERS I Tribune News Service
BILL BRAMHALL I Tribune News Service
{m&>
-<• WHO'S
WINNING?.
SCOTT STANTIS I Tribune News Service
MIKE LESTER I Washington Post Writers Group
To submit letters: Send by email to letters@
gainesvilletimes.com (no attached files) or use the
contact form at gainesvilletimes.com. Include name,
hometown and phone number; letters never appear
anonymously. Letters are limited to one per writer
in a month’s time on topics of public interest and
may be edited for content and length (limit of 500
words). Letters may be rejected from readers with no
ties to Northeast Georgia or that address personal,
business or legal disputes. Letters not the work of the
author listed or with material not properly attributed
will be rejected. Submitted items may be published
in print, electronic or other forms. Letters and other
commentary express the opinions of the authors and
not of The Times.