Newspaper Page Text
TODAYS TOP HEADLINES
The Times, Gainesville, Georgia | gainesvilletimes.com
Tuesday, December 18, 2018 3A
US sportswear traced to internment camps
ANONYMOUS I Associated Press
In this file image from undated video footage run by China’s CCTV via AP Video, Muslim
trainees work in a garment factory at the Hotan Vocational Education and Training Center in
Hotan, Xinjiang, northwest China.
BY DAKE KANG,
MARTHA MENDOZA
AND YANAN WANG
Associated Press
HOTAN, China — Chinese
men and women locked
in a mass detention camp
where authorities are “re
educating” ethnic minorities
are sewing clothes that have
been imported all year by a
U.S. sportswear company.
The camp, in Hotan, China,
is one of a growing number of
internment camps in the Xin
jiang region, where by some
estimates 1 million Muslims
are detained, forced to give
up their language and their
religion and subject to politi
cal indoctrination. Now, the
Chinese government is also
forcing some detainees to
work in manufacturing and
food industries. Some of them
are within the internment
camps; others are privately-
owned, state-subsidized facto
ries where detainees are sent
once they are released.
The Associated Press has
tracked recent, ongoing ship
ments from one such factory
— Hetian Taida Apparel —
inside an internment camp to
Badger Sportswear, a leading
supplier in Statesville, North
Carolina. Badger’s clothes
are sold on college campuses
and to sports teams across
the country, although there is
no way to tell where any par
ticular shirt made in Xinjiang
ends up.
The shipments show how
difficult it is to stop products
made with forced labor from
getting into the global sup
ply chain, even though such
imports are illegal in the U.S.
Badger CEO John Anton said
Sunday that the company
would halt shipments while it
investigates.
Hetian Taida’s chairman
Wu Hongbo confirmed that
the company has a factory
inside a re-education com
pound, and said they pro
vide employment to those
trainees who were deemed
by the government to be
“unproblematic.”
“We’re making our con
tribution to eradicating pov
erty,” Wu told the AP over
the phone.
Chinese authorities say the
camps offer free vocational
training for Uighurs, Kazakhs
and other minorities, mostly
Muslims, as part of a plan to
bring them into “a modern
civilized” world and elimi
nate poverty in the region.
They say that people in the
centers have signed agree
ments to receive vocational
training.
The Xinjiang Propaganda
Department did not respond
to a faxed request for com
ment. A Chinese Foreign Min
istry spokeswoman accused
the foreign media Monday
of making “many untrue
reports” about the training
centers, but did not specify
when asked for details.
“Those reports are com
pletely based on hearsay
evidence or made out of thin
air,” the spokeswoman, Hua
Chunying, said at a daily
briefing.
However, a dozen people
who either had been in a
camp or had friends or fam
ily in one told the AP that
detainees they knew were
given no choice but to work
at the factories. Most of the
Uighurs and Kazakhs, who
were interviewed in exile,
also said that even people
with professional jobs were
retrained to do menial work.
Payment varied according
to the factory. Some got paid
nothing, while others earned
up to several hundred dollars
a month, they said — barely
above minimum wage for the
poorer parts of Xinjiang. A
person with firsthand knowl
edge of the situation in one
county estimated that more
than 10,000 detainees — or
10 to 20 percent of the intern
ment population there — are
working in factories, with
some earning just a tenth
of what they used to earn
before. The person declined
to be named out of fear of
retribution.
A former reporter for Xin
jiang TV in exile said that
during his month-long deten
tion last year, young people in
his camp were taken away in
the mornings to work without
compensation in carpentry
and a cement factory.
“The camp didn’t pay any
money, not a single cent,” he
said, asking to be identified
only by his first name, Elyar,
because he has relatives
still in Xinjiang. “Even for
necessities, such as things to
shower with or sleep at night,
they would call our families
outside to get them to pay for
it.”
Rushan Abbas, a Uighur
in Washington, D.C., said
her sister is among those
detained. The sister, Dr.
Gulshan Abbas, was taken to
what the government calls a
vocational center, although
she has no specific informa
tion on whether her sister is
being forced to work.
“American companies
importing from those places
should know those products
are made by people being
treated like slaves,” she
said. “What are they going
to do, train a doctor to be a
seamstress?”
Mainur Medetbek’s hus
band did odd repair jobs
before vanishing into a camp
in February during a visit to
China from their home in
Kazakhstan. She has been
able to glean a sense of his
conditions from monitored
exchanges with relatives
and from the husband of a
woman in the same camp. He
works in an apparel factory
and is allowed to leave and
spend the night with relatives
every other Saturday.
Though Medetbek is
uncertain how much her
husband makes, the woman
in his camp earns 600 yuan
(about $87) a month, less than
half the local minimum wage
and far less than what Medet
bek’s husband used to earn.
“They say it’s a factory, but
it’s an excuse for detention.
They don’t have freedom,
there’s no time for him to talk
with me,” she said. “They
say they found a job for him.
I think it’s a concentration
camp.”
New Jersey Republican
Congressman Chris Smith, a
member of the House For
eign Relations Committee,
called on the Trump Admin
istration Monday to ban
imports from Chinese com
panies associated with deten
tion camps.
“Not only is the Chinese
government detaining over
a million Uyghurs and other
Muslims, forcing them to
revoke their faith and pro
fess loyalty to the Communist
Party, they are now profiting
from their labor,” said Smith.
“U.S. consumers should not
be buying and U.S. businesses
should not importing goods
made in modern-day concen
tration camps. “
Flynn’s ex-business associates charged with illegal lobbying
JACQUELYN MARTIN I Associated Press
Bijan Kian, whose full name is Bijan Rafiekian, leaves the FBI Washington
Field Office in Washington, Monday, Dec. 17. Rafiekian, a one-time
business partner of former National Security Adviser Michael Flynn, has
been indicted on charges including failing to register as a foreign agent.
BY MATTHEW BARAKAT
AND CHAD DAY
Associated Press
ALEXANDRIA, Va. — Two
business associates of Michael
Flynn, President Donald Trump’s
former national security adviser,
were charged Monday with ille
gally lobbying for Turkey as part of
a campaign to pressure the United
States to expel a Turkish cleric.
Bijan Kian and Ekim Alptekin
are accused in an indictment of
conspiring to “covertly and unlaw
fully” influence U.S. public opinion
and politicians, all while conceal
ing that the Turkish government
was directing their work. The cam
paign came during the final months
of the 2016 presidential campaign
while Flynn was a top surrogate for
Trump’s campaign.
The case sheds further light on
how Flynn and those around him
worked to benefit a foreign country
in the months before he became
one of America’s top national secu
rity officials. The goal of the work
was to get the United States to expel
Turkish cleric Fethullah Gulen
from the country.
Gulen, who holds a U.S. green
card and lives in Pennsylvania, is
a rival of Turkish President Recep
Tayyip Erdogan, who has accused
the cleric of directing a failed coup
and who wanted the U.S. to extra
dite him back to Turkey. Gulen
has denied any involvement in the
coup.
Though Flynn and his company
feature prominently in the latest
indictment, he is not charged with
any new crimes. A retired three-
star U.S. Army general, Flynn is to
be sentenced Tuesday in a separate
case brought by special counsel
Robert Mueller, who is investigat
ing Russian interference in the 2016
election. Flynn has pleaded guilty
to lying about his Russian contacts.
As part of his cooperation in that
probe, he has provided prosecutors
with voluminous records from his
business, Flynn Intel Group, which
carried out the lobbying work.
Flynn and Kian were co-founders
of the firm.
On Monday, Kian, a former
Trump transition official whose
full name is Bijan Rafiekian, made
a brief appearance in federal court
in Alexandria, Virginia. He has an
arraignment scheduled for Tues
day. His lawyer, Robert Trout,
declined to comment.
Alptekin, a dual Turkish-Dutch
citizen living in Istanbul whose full
name is Kamil Ekim Alpetekin,
remains at large. He has previously
denied any wrongdoing and said he
directed the lobbying on his own.
“Ekim maintains that the gov
ernment of Turkey was not a partic
ipant in any of the work that he did
with the Flynn Intel Group. He has
not changed his story, and he does
not plan to,” said Molly Toomey, a
spokeswoman for Alptekin.
Both men are charged with
conspiracy and acting as an
unregistered agent of a foreign gov
ernment. Alptekin is also charged
with lying during an interview with
the FBI.
The indictment brought by fed
eral prosecutors in Virginia accuses
the two men of using Alptekin’s
company as a cutout to disguise
the Turkish government’s involve
ment. Prosecutors say that Turkish
officials approved the budget for
the $600,000 lobbying contract and
received regular progress reports.
The indictment does not say
Turkey’s government directly
funded the effort, but it raises
questions about an unusual pay
ment arrangement revealed
last year.
According to the indictment,
Alptekin paid Flynn’s firm through
wire transfers from a Turkish
bank account in his name.
But prosecutors say he also
received portions of the money
as “kickbacks” arranged by Kian.
Flynn’s company was ultimately
paid $530,000. Alptekin has said
the payments were refunds for
unfulfilled work.
The indictment also provides
the backstory behind a Nov. 8,
2016, op-ed Flynn published in The
Hill newspaper titled “Our Ally
Turkey Is in Crisis and Needs Our
Support,” which compares Gulen
to Iran’s Ayatollah Khomeini. The
indictment notes that Flynn’s col
umn uses identical or very similar
language to that prepared by Kian
in a draft op-ed.
“We all remember another
quiet, bearded elder cleric who sat
under an apple tree ... in the sub
urbs of Paris in 1978,” Flynn wrote
in the op-ed, mimicking language
provided to him by Kian. “He
claimed to be a man of God who
wanted to be a dictator.”
Several days before the col
umn was published, Kian crowed
to Alptekin in an email about the
advantageous timing of the pend
ing op-ed piece coinciding with
Election Day. “The arrow has left
the bow!”
Russia social media influence efforts active, ongoing report says
BY MARY CLARE JALONICK
Associated Press
WASHINGTON — Rus
sia’s sweeping political dis
information campaign on
U.S. social media was more
far-reaching than originally
thought, with troll farms
working to discourage black
voters and “blur the lines
between reality and fiction”
to help elect Donald Trump
in 2016, according to reports
released Monday by the Sen
ate intelligence committee.
And the campaign didn’t
end with Trump’s ascent to
the White House. Troll farms
are still working to stoke
racial and political passions
in America at a time of high
political discord.
The two studies are the
most comprehensive picture
yet of the Russian interfer
ence campaigns on Ameri
can social media. They add
to the portrait investigators
have been building since
2017 on Russia’s influence
— though Trump has equivo
cated on whether the inter
ference actually happened.
Facebook, Google and
Twitter declined to com
ment on the specifics of the
reports.
The reports were compiled
by the cybersecurity firm
New Knowledge and by the
Computational Propaganda
Save
Your Selfie...
Some Moneyl
Auto Insurance
Specialist
• Easy Payments
• Any Driver
• Any Age
NEW LOCATION!
2415 OLD CORNELIA HWY., GAINESVILLE
Next to Rabbittown Cafe
770-450-4500
Research Project, a study by
researchers at the University
of Oxford and Graphika, a
social media analysis firm.
The Oxford report details
how Russians broke down
their messages to different
groups, including discourag
ing black voters from going
to the polls and stoking anger
on the right.
“These campaigns pushed
a message that the best way
to advance the cause of the
African-American commu
nity was to boycott the elec
tion and focus on other issues
instead,” the researchers
wrote.
At the same time, “Mes
saging to conservative and
right-wing voters sought to
do three things: repeat patri
otic and anti-immigrant slo
gans; elicit outrage with posts
about liberal appeasement of
‘others’ at the expense of US
citizens, and encourage them
to vote for Trump.”
The report from New
Knowledge says there are
still some live accounts
tied to the original Internet
Research Agency, which
was named in an indictment
from special counsel Robert
Mueller in February for an
expansive social media cam
paign intended to influence
the 2016 presidential elec
tion. Some of the accounts
have a presence on smaller
•Gift baskets
•Embroidery
•Unique gifts
•Screen printing
•Balloons for all occasions
•Full Service Pharmacy
•Free Local Delivery
•Compounding Unit Dose
Packaging
Hiverride fharmaqj
935 Green St., Gainesville, GA
770.532.6253 • callriversidepharmacy.com
platforms as the major com
panies have tried to clean up
after the Russian activity was
discovered.
“With at least some of
the Russian government’s
goals achieved in the face
of little diplomatic or other
pushback, it appears likely
that the United States will
continue to face Russian
interference for the foresee
able future,” the researchers
wrote.
EARLY DEADLINES FOR
CHRISTMAS DAY
Because of the upcoming Christmas Day holiday The Times
will alter its advertising and legals deadline as follows:
Retail Display Ads
Publication
The Times
Date
Deadline
Wednesday
12/26
Friday, 12/21
Thursday
12/27
Friday, 12/21
Classified Line Ads
Publication
The Times
Date
Deadline
Wednesday
12/26
Friday, 12/21 @3pm
Legal Ads
Publication
The Times
Date
Deadline
Wednesday
12/26
Wednesday, 12/19 @ 5pm
Thursday
12/27
Wednesday, 12/19 @ 5pm
dte Eftties
gainesvilletimes •com
will be CLOSED Tuesday,
December 25th, in observance of Christmas.