Newspaper Page Text
4A Sunday, May 21,2023
The Times, Gainesville, Georgia | gainesvilletimes.com
NATION
Gorsuch: Emergency orders were intrusion on liberties
J. SCOn APPLEWHITE I Associated Press
Associate Justice Neil Gorsuch joins other members of the Supreme Court as they pose for
a new group portrait, at the Supreme Court building in Washington, Friday, Oct. 7.
BY MARK SHERMAN
Associated Press
WASHINGTON — The
Supreme Court got rid of
a pandemic-related immi
gration case with a single
sentence.
Justice Neil Gorsuch had
a lot more to say, level
ing harsh criticism of how
governments, from small
towns to the nation’s capi
tal, responded to the grav
est public health threat in a
century.
The justice, a 55-year-
old conservative who was
President Donald Trump’s
first Supreme Court nomi
nee, called emergency
measures taken during the
COVID-19 crisis that killed
more than 1 million Ameri
cans perhaps “the greatest
intrusions on civil liberties
in the peacetime history of
this country.”
He pointed to orders
closing schools, restricting
church services, mandat
ing vaccines and prohibit
ing evictions. His broadside
was aimed at local, state
and federal officials —
even his colleagues.
“Executive officials
across the country issued
emergency decrees on a
breathtaking scale,” Gor
such wrote in an eight-page
statement Thursday that
accompanied an expected
Supreme Court order for
mally dismissing a case
involving the use of the
Title 42 policy to prevent
asylum seekers from enter
ing the United States.
The policy was ended
last week with the expira
tion of the public health
emergency first declared
more than three years ago
because of the coronavirus
pandemic.
From the start of his
Supreme Court tenure in
2017, Gorsuch, a Colorado
native who loves to ski and
bicycle, has been more
willing than most justices to
part company with his col
leagues, both left and right.
He has mainly voted with
the other conservatives in
his six years as a justice,
joining the majority that
overturned Roe v. Wade
and expanded gun rights
last year.
But he has charted a
different course on some
issues, writing the court’s
2020 opinion that extended
federal protections against
workplace discrimination
to LGBTQ people. He also
has joined with the liberal
justices in support of Native
American rights.
When the omicron vari
ant surged in late 2021 and
early 2022, Gorsuch was the
lone justice to appear in the
courtroom unmasked even
as his seatmate, Justice
Sonia Sotomayor, who has
diabetes, reportedly did not
feel safe in close quarters
with people who were not
wearing masks.
So Sotomayor, who con
tinues to wear a mask in
public, did not take the
bench with the other jus
tices in January 2022. The
two justices denied reports
they were at odds over the
issue.
The emergency orders
about which Gorsuch
complained were first
announced in the early
days of the pandemic, when
Trump was president, and
months before the virus
was well understood and a
vaccine was developed.
The thrust of his com
plaint is not new. He has
written before in individ
ual cases that came to the
court during the pandemic,
sometimes dissenting from
orders that left emergency
decrees in place.
The justices intervened
in several COVID-related
cases.
With Gorsuch and five
other conservatives in the
majority, they ended the
eviction moratorium and
blocked a Biden admin
istration plan to require
workers at larger compa
nies to be vaccinated or
wear a mask and submit to
regular testing. Once Amy
Coney Barrett joined the
court, after Ruth Bader
Ginsburg died, they ended
restrictions on religious ser
vices in some areas.
By a 5-4 vote from which
Gorsuch and three conser
vative colleagues dissented,
the court allowed the
administration to require
many health care workers
to be vaccinated.
But on Thursday, Gor
such gathered his com
plaints in one place, writing
about lessons he hoped
might be learned from the
past three years.
“One lesson might be
this: Fear and the desire
for safety are powerful
forces. They can lead to a
clamor for action —almost
any action — as long as
someone does something to
address a perceived threat.
A leader or an expert who
claims he can fix every
thing, if only we do exactly
as he says, can prove an
irresistible force,” he
wrote.
Another possible lesson,
he wrote: “The concentra
tion of power in the hands
of so few may be efficient
and sometimes popular.
But it does not tend toward
sound government.”
a Apartments
FOR RENT
RPC Partners
2 Bedrin. Apartments
Gainesville, Oakwood & Flowery Branch
$ 300 Move in Special
Plus Deposit
770-654-2807
NOW HIRING
Off-Road Truck Drivers, Scraper Operators,
and CDL Drivers/Heavy Equipment Operator
Competitive pay, Great Benefits
(401 k, Health Ins., Vacation)
Apply in Person
1364 Candler Rd. Gainesville, Ga 30507
Monday - Friday 8am - 5pm
770-536-4731 Ext. 1
PROFESSIONAL DIRECTORY AND SERVICE GUIDE
To place your company’s advertisement, call us today at
770-535-1199
Make your woods look like a park
Corp Approved Lake Paths and Steps • Trenching
Grading/Landscaping • Retaining Walls
Timber and Beautiful Anchor Diamond Walls
laT N t S td
^STAB iEU
SMALL JOBS O.K.
Drainage/Erosion Problems
Semi-Retired • Affordable
Mulch • Gravel • Sand
River Rock • Fill Dirt
Top Soil • White Marble
Red Rock & More
WE DELIVER!
/W/ke 678-410-1375
www.ngabeds.com
Customer Pick-Up is also available
We Accept All Major Credit Cards
1364 Candler Rd
Gainesville, Ga 30507
770-534-6928
770-536-4731
and Split Firewood
rl0Sn wUU • 8 FT Railroad cross ties
> •TifTuf Bermuda
| •Rebel Fescue
- •TifBlair Centipede
•Zeon Zoysia
•Marvel Zoysia
* Onfii
8FT Railroad cross ties
• 8FT 6x6 Pressure Treated Posts
• 10FT 6x6 Pressure Treated Posts
• 12FT 6x6 Pressure Treated Posts
TIFTUF Rebel reaaagi
divisions of GEORGIA'S FINEST PINE STRAW & MULCH
PrmumTOp'
Check in Today
for our
New Specials!
Ml OtMMLi &MI EMMS
Pine straw and mulch year round
mm ^§xgc£ wwm
All Varieties of Rock now Available
1 Sand m Rip Rap Stone 4 57 Stone • River Rock-all sizes
Field Stone • Flag Stone • River Rock Boulders
Field Stone Boulders • Ashlan • Tumbles Cobble Stone
WDr
Double Ground Hardwood Mulch
Erosion control
mats and
New Crop long needle pine straw super red s j| t f ences now
Bag & Bulk Hardwood Mulch in available!
red, black, brown, mini pine nugget & top soil.
We Sell • We Service • We Finance
Equipment Hauling Trailers - Enclosed Cargo
Vans - Landscape Trailers - Dump Trailers
We have full service repair shop for all types of trailers. Monday-Friday 8-5 and Saturday 8-2 pm.
Also we have a parts department for all trailer needs
Open Monday-Friday 7am-5pm & Saturday 7am-2pm
770-287-8300
2650 Browns Bridge Road * Gainesville, GA 30504 • www.georgiasfinestpinestraw.com