The Southern Israelite. (Augusta, Ga.) 1925-1986, September 19, 1986, Image 4
PAGE 4 THE SOUTHERN ISRAELITE September 19, 1986
The Southern Israelite
The We«My Newspaper For Southern Je^-'ty
Since 1925
Vida Goldgar Jeff Rubin
Editor General Manager
Luna Levy
Managing Editor
Published by Sun Publications, Inc.
also publishers of The Kansas City Jewish Chronicle
Stan Rose Steve Rose
Chairman and President and
Publisher Co-Publisher
Second Class Postage paid at Atlanta, Ga. (ISSN 003S8) (UPS 776060)
POSTMASTER: Send address changes to The Southern Israelite, P.O. Box
77388, Atlanta, GA 30357
Mailing Address: P.O. Box 77388, Atlanta, Georgia 30357
Location: 188 15th St., N.W., AH., Ga. 30318 Phone (404)876-8248
Advertising rates available upon request.
Subscriptions: $23.00, 1 year; $41.00, 2 years
Member of Jewish Telegraphic Agency; Religious News Service;
American Jewish Press Assn.; Georgia Press Assn.; National Newspaper Assn.
Ridiculous charge
One of Israel’s proudest moments was the massive rescue operation of
Ethiopian Jews. And not just the rescue but the absorption into everyday
life in the Jewish state.
Hardly a week goes by that we do not hear a heartwarming story of
how the Ethiopian Jews are making their place. This week, on page 8,
there is an enchanting picture of youngsters who have taken up Little
League baseball.
Yet, in Wednesday’s Atlanta Journal and Atlanta Constitution, we
read of a group calling themselves the Original African Hebrew Israelite
Nation of Jerusalem — Black Hebrews for short. They claim that the
reason Israel has deported some of them and is seeking to deport others
whom Israel contends are illegal aliens is “unadulterated racism.’’
A little history is in order, and the American Jewish Committee has
done a thorough study on the subject. The story of Black Hebrews is not
exactly new. The group began in the black ghettos of Chicago and other
cities in the early 1960s. Their ideology claims they, not the Jews, are the
true descendants of the Biblical People of Israel, and as such, Israel
belongs to them.
But the earlier members of the sect didn’t head straight for Israel.
Numbers of them migrated to Liberia in West Africa. But, according to
the AJC report, the black Liberian government, with no fear of being
seen as anti-black, expelled them around 1969. Their leader, Ben-Ami
Carter, led his people to Israel, where they settled in Dimona.
It didn’t take long until, having long overstayed their welcome as
tourists, tensions arose. Their closed, cultic lifestyle brought friction with
the townspeople and their anti-Israel statements didn’t help.
Because of the sensitivity of the issue, the situation bubbled beneath
the surface for 16 years, while the original group grew to about 3,000 both
through birth and by additional “tourists” melding into the community.
Still, defectors claim Ben-Ami Carter dominates the sect with charis
matic control and incidents of physical abuse of adults and children are
reported. There are reports, too, that there may be a link with subversive
Palestinian-Arabs.
This is not a simple problem, either for the Israel authorities or for the
Black Hebrews here. It can’t be clearly addressed in an editorial.
But what is clear is that the claims that their problems stem from the
fact that they are black is ridiculous.
Vida Goldgar
‘Memo from Russia’
#
A lot of you have been asking me when you’ll get to
meet our new publishers, the Roses. I promise you,
that time will come before long ami they are just_a^
anxious to meet you.
Since I can’t quite yet have the
pleasure of introducing you to them,
1 can at least give you a reader’s
acquaintance with Stan and Shir
ley, through his book, “Memo from
Russia,” observations on a
month-long trip from Moscow to
Mongolia, with a side trip to
Siberia.
Stan Rose is a newspaperman from way back and
the 10,000-mile trip, which began just a year ago, was
under the auspices of the National Newspaper Associ
ation. The book was an expansion on a series of
columns Stan wrote for his Sun Publications in Kan
sas City.
Most of what we read from returnees from the
U.S.S.R. is limited to the major cities, Moscow,
Leningrad, Kiev; writers stress the political scene and
their visits are somewhat restricted by the regulation
“trmrist” nrnoram Not sn here As Steve Rose, their
son, wrote in the foreword. Stan “has the unique
ability to discern a mosaic from his travels, blending
together the political, economic and man-in-the-street
picture of a nation.” I haven’t seen the films they were
able to smuggle out, but I have read the book. And I
can easily believe the comment Stan says he’s heard
most often: “You’ve shown us a side of Russia we
haven’t seen before.”
His story is not that of Moscow-based reporters,
whom he says “are as much prisoners of the political
system as are the 280 million citizens of the Soviet
Union” who have to live in “special compounds for
foreigners.” The current situation of Nick Daniloff,
who was arrested on the flimsiest of trumped-up
charges, only emphasizes Stan’s view. Yet, he says,
“Beneath the average Russian’s suspicious, unfriendly
and sometimes rude exterior, sometimes lies a warmth
toward America that seems to reject the baloney com
ing out of the Kremlin.”
They broke the ice with Shirley’s Polaroid camera,
brought into service in the Ukraine. It wasn’t easy.
Their friendly overtures were first met with cold dis
dain. But once they were able to convince a young girl
in Tashkent to pose, a crowd gathered to watch the
developing process. Shirley snapped away and handed
out the pictures, each time saying, “America,” and
putting out her hand. The grateful “models” grasped
her hand and responded “America...Da.” It worked in
the Ukraine, in Siberia and all over the country, as
Shirley gave away more than 100 Polaroid pictures.
They didn’t keep any of those, but the book is full
of other photographs, including a pixieish one
snapped by a friend, with Stan committing the ulti
mate sacrilege of sitting himself at Lenin’s desk in a
memorial room at the Smolny Institute in Leningrad.
A wide-eyed watchful Shirley stands behind him.
waiting for the worst.
“Memo from Russia” is a combination of wit and
deep insights. It ranges from descriptions of “stinking
public toilets” and getting caught up in a Russian
wedding celebration at a “non-tourist” Soviet pec-
topah (restaurant), to a serious discussion with a
Soviet diplomat about Afghanistan. There are exam
ples of the inflexible Soviet bureaucracy and a heart
breaking visit with Evgeny Yakir, a refusnik.
For all that, one of the most fascinating sections of
the 161-page paperback book is Stan and Shirley’s
35-hour train ride from Irkutsk, Siberia, to Ulan
Bator, the capital of the People’s Republic of Mongo
lia. It’s less than 700 miles, but at one point they had to
wait almost a full day for a new engine. More hours
were spent at a customs inspection stop, where their
video camera and other cameras were ignored, while
the inspector challenged Stan’s copy of Lee Iacocca’s
autobiography and Shirley’s mystery book.
There is a synagogue in Irkutsk, serving the 8,000
Jews there. It is on the second floor of a 100-year-old
brick building. I thought the only Jews in Siberia were
in labor camps. Not so. Mordechai and Zvi offered the
Roses matzo already baked for the next Passover.
Mordechai told them that five or six hundred people
come for Yom Kippur, but there is not a minyan the
rest of the year, “...the young people don’t come. It’s
strictly the alte," he said.
They had heard the same thing in Kiev. Whenever
a young person attended services...“he would get a
visit from a Communist spokesman who would
remind him that the Soviet Union is an atheistic state
and that his future would be jeopardized if he prac
ticed his religion.” It is the same for Christians. Stan
writes. Yet Moslems, who live in great numbers near
the borders of Afghanistan and Iran are allowed to
follow their customs and religious beliefs.
Despite the restrictions and the bitter cold of Si
beria, Stan writes that Mordechai seemed shocked when
asked if he would like to emigrate to Israel: “What for?
We live well here. They don’t bother us. Many of our
most important professors, scientists, advocates (law
yers) and doctors here are Jews. Gorbachev needles
the Russians. He tells them in his speeches that one
Jew can do what it takes three Russians to do.”
They weren’t allowed to go Birobidzhan, but
Soviet maps still show the Jewish Autonomous Region
of the Soviet Union deep in the Russian Far East
Territory. But Birobidzhan is there. They saw it from
the train. Yet, Stan writes, with a “land whose soil can
be planted only 75 to 90 days a year, because the
temperature drops to 40 to 50 degrees below zero from
November to May” who would want to live there?
The scary part of the trip came when they got
ready to leave. How to get the video cassettes out. But
they did, hidden under their clothing. And, as Stan
said to Shirley once they were safe, “So what would
they have done to us...send us to Siberia? “We’re
already there.”
Babi Yar
by Stanley M. Lefco
KIEV, Sept. 27, 1941: Posters
throughout the city demand that
Jews assemble for “resettlement.”
More than 30,000 report. They are
taken to Babi Yar, a ravine just
outside the city. There, they are
brutally executed. The horror is
unimaginable. On this 45th anni
versary of the slaughter at Babi
Yar, we remember the victims by
recalling the story of Dina Proni-
chcva, who miraculously managed
to escape. She told her story to the
Russian writer, Anatoli Kuznetsov.
Martin Gilbert in his monumental
work. “The Holocaust," quotes from
his work:
“All around and beneath her she
could hear strange submerged
sounds, groaning, chokingand sob
bing: many of the people were not
dead yet. The whole mass of bodies
kept moving slightly as they settled
down and were pressed tighter by
the movements of the ones who
were still living.
“Some soldiers came out on to
the ledge and flashed their torches
down on the bodies, firing bullets
from their revolvers into any which
appeared to be still living. But
someone not far from Dina went
on groaning as loud as before.
“Then she heard people walking
near her, actually on the bodies.
They were Germans who had climbed
down and were bent over and tak
ing things from the dead and occa
sionally firing at those which
showed signs ol life. Among them
was lhe policeman who had exam
ined her papers and taken her bag:
she recognized him by his voice.
“One SS-man caught his foot
against Dina and her appearance
aroused his suspicions. He shone
his torch on her, picked her up and
struck her with his fist. But she
hung limp and gave no signs of life
He kicked her in the breast with his
heavy boot and trod on her right
hand so that the bones cracked,
but he didn’t use his gun and went
off, picking his way across the
corpses.
“A few minutes later she heard a
voice calling from above. ‘Demi-
denko! Come on, start shoveling!
“There was a clatter of spades
and then heavy thuds as the earth
and sand landed on the bodies,
coming closer and closer until i
Continued next pag e '