The Republican ; and Savannah evening ledger. (Savannah, Ga.) 1807-1816, June 27, 1807, Image 2
TUiAL OV LOLUNLL buRK.
FEDERAL COURT.
JOci/M'jND, Safurduy Morning, June 13.
Tlic court have been occupied during the
last Ui cc (L)b, on llie -motion to obtain a xub
jiiC ia duees tecum, aiiurtssed to the Piosiilcnt
ui ait Untied ‘tales.
vVc h.ne net ..lied a part of the argument
that w..s iiiuiu . iiicu fii \\ chut sduy on this mb
ject. .or. Mai tin was im. iiuii by Messis.
M’Grae. Betts, ..lit ai.u v\ ickhain.
. In t Inn suav the grand jtuy wcie adjourn
ed o.e.r ml ton y : ui.o lue atgumeiit was
remlined by Mi. li-y, who was succcencd by
Mr. Randolph.
On Friday, the argument was continued by
Mr ..ui in an*l closed by Mr. lluir Ihe
court have not yet given tneii dec smnoti this
interesting point, .vlr. Burr obxe> vtd,that us
general vViikiuson mi,,hi now be expected in
li short time befme the court, i. Was utuiable
to obtain u prompt decision.
On the conclusion ot this argument, JVr
-11 n r addressed the court : i.c observed that
this was perhaps the most proper lime for ic
newing the motion, wideh he hud seme time
ago made to the court, about giving more spe
cific, instructions to the grand jury, on certain
points of eviuence. 1 hese [mints he liad re
duced to wilting in the form of abstiact propo
sitions. whicti he would take the liberty oi lead
ing to the com t :
The following is a list of those propositions
with the authorities cited to support them :
1. That the grand jury cuntiot, consistently
evilh their oath, find a bill escept on such te -
tiinonv as woiil I justify a petit jury to find
tin prisoner guil y. .
Foilrr, 23 ■ trc. B—3d, Irft'lu'e, 25—'d InOitute,
;|HI— Ultnn, a, ‘l—Judge Willoti’n works, vol. .:tl.
3 I —| W. Wil iams’ Jultice, lid. Vol. primed
179*—:|.l State T 1i 9.42 H and Sir John Haw it’s
ohl rvatmns, I .s. I , 18:1 Irh li ark. 3,)2 t* 306--
gd Hale, chap. 8, page 6l Wilfmi't edition w.th
Wilton’s note—2d Hale, chap. 22, page 1.37, with
Wi fnn'ii note—vd Male, ch ip 22, page 16<r, with
Wi Inn’s noit—l unnmos riici 2d fee. 39 page. 124
5-6—state I', page 3—Falter, page 2.12, tec. 8.
2. 1 nat no tciiiiiionv or witnesses ought to
go to tlie grantl jury but whui are legal and
in npcicui to siipnort the charge about which
the enquiry is made.
l*anby’ Cife, I rath, 443, chap 187—Dodd’s case,
I each, .39 chip 77—Coin iionwealttvoi Virginia vs
II iplia n. VVar.es and llaan, helure the C3. v-ouit at
M ntianifburg,
3. In lino rand jury cannot return a bill
for trea ion lor levying war against me United
Stales, unless llioy n ive t.vo wiinessc > who
swear to tne overt act ol the treason laid in the
i idii inieiii; both which witnesses are believ
ed hv them.
Rail’s Ciown • arv,chip. 2d sec. 54.
1 liat both mult be t>e.ir,a :td Hate trials page 38.
4. I nut there, must Le o™ witnesses to the
grand tury of each overt act, inflows also as a
r""‘ ‘| eiu.e fro in lie former position, that
they must have such testimony as would he
requisite for the petit jury.
•> 1 hat the grand jury cannot find a bill for
treason in consequence of any confessions
m ule, though proved by two witnesses.
Fofier, 241-3. 4 B*ack.
Conllitutioti of the U. S article 3d. fee. 3 Tnydnn’s
Digefl, 11—Judge Iredell’* charge—Frits’trial, 171
172 v tall, 86 <J7.
6.1 hat as tit • g mh:l jury only hear evidence
on the p triolihe state.it upon mat evidence
they entei tain a doubt of tne truth of the
c h irge. they ought not to find the bid, as the
pi vs 1 1 option is ever in favor of innocence.
Ift McNally, 2to .
7. Si uci Ot a ihii and person can he given in
evidence agu list the accused to prove him
g .ii.y ol treason, or ol a misdemeanor undo
tpc law of 5 h June, 1794. unless that act is
proved inline been com nil ted hv the advice,
e niiiii.ind, dreeti'i'i. or instigation of the accu
sed, il done ii his absence, or if done in his
piesence, unless it be prove I that the accused
v ,s .a ling nr assisting. ,
A” afl th*t| hind a perfoti ennnedfed with tl e adt, hut
the il, .laratioa lha.li not bind him, bicaulc no part of
the act.
McNal'y, 815 to 618.
8. The declarations of others cannot lie giv
en in ew feme on the present en juicy to s p
j> i 11 ne charge ol treason, or of a misdemeanor
under die act of con ‘l ess, 15th June. 1794, un
less u ne proven dial the accused was present
an I i-se 1 e tre eto.
Ra*l. 9 —’n csf* of confniracy,confidliivit good a"aintt
him who nv.ik them, hm a t a uml> nrher, I’t-ak •
li. Cos ih''. Peake 7 Heart u—Kelyin* 18cl M
McNatiy. 4 >-41, coufcili.iu* of one cannot be re.id
againll other*.
3d tare fill, 574.
A relation of what had brtn done no evidence.
McNally 6IS.
Die iratiin* of o'hvra ia not evidence.
4 llitetria’, 199-198.
6 stare I'riaa, 218, in the pretence ofothera, the, ac
gaiefcug.
McNally, 621.
Mr. llvt opposed this proceeding Hr
contended, that the court had no right to give,
specific instructions to the grand jury, alter
thev h id b eti once generally charged bv the
court ; that such a course was contrary to all
1 iw .aid all precedent, that nota single instance
cniitd be qumed to siipjxirt it ; and that the e
we e cogent and in this inst nice particular rea
s ns whv ci i.ntiutl prosecutions sh mid he suf
f ■ ed to progress wi limit these interruptions
H • further contended, that the Cnief Justi. e
hil antieinted such a situation ; and that the
language in his clearly indicated his
esn—tatton that this would he laid before the
gn and i>irv on the gmun i of tre ison ; and <h if
UUUtp tuts expectation, the Chief Justice had
dilated on the r.ahirc of treason, and given all
the infoimation which he thought material;
that there were no reason at all, why A. Burr
should enjoy greater piivileges than any oilier
man ; why he should take up all the old, mus
ty, and absurd doctrines of antiquity and have
them enlisted in his service ; and that he stood
on the very same ground as any other man :
that jierhaps all the propositions on Mr. Bui r’s
list would not lie v anting at all ; or it tiiere
should he any necessity for them, that these
questions might be discussed as they succes
sively arose ; that these discussions wuulu i.e
ces ai in consume much of lus own time as
well as the time of the court, which might pic
bably fie devoted to moie useful purposes : and
alter all. the grand jury might leluse to hear
any instructions, and in that case, how couid
they be commuted by the court j If the grand
jury determined to jiay no regard to it, ol what
avail would he the recommendation ot the
couit, for it was in fact no more ? And il
they were to find according to their own opin
ions, and in the old way, how could the court
know of this variation ? And how could they
rectify it ?
Mr. Botts replied. Ho stated that the
gentleman had demanded precedents ; and
yet it was blit the oilier day when that very
gentleman kd enquired, w'hy w - c so constant
ly resorted to piecedetits ; and why “e old not
sometimes consult tlie principles ot common
sense : that the grand jury were not that law
less mob, which the gentleman had seemed to
represent them ; and that they would not cer
tainly act against the law, when it was proper
ty expounded to them by the hi ad of the court;
that although the chief justice’s cha’.gc was
extremely able, yet it was impossible that ii
could he so comprehensive as it might now he
made, from the information which has since
occurred ; and that the very necessity of gn
ing any charge at all, shewed the propriety ol
perfecting it ; that it was not colonel Burr s
desire to co'sume much time, as it was his
most earnest ns ;h to end at once the bonds ol
recognizance and the public prejudice, whicti
surrounded him : and that they were even
willing to limit their share of the discussion to
a particular time.
I he Ciiikf Justick said, that it was usual
and the lx stcourse for the couit to charge the
pity generally, at the commencement of the
term, anil to give their opinion on incidental
points as they arose, when the grand jury,
themselves, should apply to them for informa
tion ; that it was manifestly improper to com
mit the opinion of the court on points, which
might come before them, to he decided on the
trial in chief; that he had generally confined
his charges to a few general jxiinls, without
launching into many details ; one reason was,
that some of the detailed points might never
ai tse during the session of the grand jury, and
any instruction on them, would of com se, be
unnecessary ; another was, that some ot these
points might he extremely difficult to be, deci
ded, and would require an argument of coun
sel ; because there was no judge or nrum, who
would not often find the solitary meditations of
his closet very much assisted by tlie discus
sions of others ; that he would have had no
difficulty, however, in expanding his charge, ii
he had been particularly requested to do it, or
if he could have aa’injvated any necessity for
it, and that he would have no difficulty in giv
ing his opinions at this time on certain points,
on which lie could obtain a discussion by the
counsel, provided he did not. tneteby commit
Ins opinion oil the trial in chief.
Mr Burr then requested him to inspect
the list of p opositions which lie had prepared;
lie might then determine which of those points
would admit of the delivety of his opinion ;
and which would not
The list is now in the possession of the court:
and here the business rests for the present.
The gentleman who came out to summon
witnesses on the puit of die United States,
passed through this place some few days since,
on lus way to Richmond, lie had obtained
very important testimony against Burr ; had
summoned several wi.nesses and taken their
depositions, with which he was hurrying on to
lav before the Uniteh States attorney. Should
tin: 1 1 i it ol Burr commence on llic2-d, as con
cluded on, we apprehend he will be acquitted
for want of testimony.— Much testimony is yet
in tins country; and as some of those who
couid give very essential evidence were once
before the grand jury who tried colonel Burr
here, we leel some anxiety to know how they
have ucqimcd their knowledge of lus schemes.
It appears that Mr. Wood. “ The man of
the world.” has taken French leave of his
friends in W ishington. No doubt his busi
ness was so urgent, that a longer delay would
have been injurious to his idea of liberty. His
elopement was so sudden, that even his part
ner was not apprised of the extraordinary
movement.— Frederick Town fiafier.
It appears from the following paragraph,
that Mr Carpenter, editor of th* “ People's
Put'.no \xn Daily Advertiser.” in New-
Yoi k, has again failed in his utte nip's to con
vince the citizens of the United States that they
are “ their own worst enemies.”
“ rhe subscriber, having determined to with
draw himself from editing of the “People’s
Friend and Daily Advertiser, ” gives this
public, notice that that establishment is now
offered for sale, Aiy person disposed to pur
chase, will find it an object worthy of attention.
The terms will lie ma le convenient in jaoint of
time to die purchaser.
“ S. C. Carp ENTER.”
TIIE DRIVER, SLOOP OF WAR.
From the New York Aurora.
The late insolence ot the captain of this ves
sel in the harbor of Charleston, has excited the
snongesl indignation in eveiy American breast.
i\o man can feel too much on this occasion,
and none feels more than the writer of this ar
ticle. But, while we aie orejielled by an honest
; n ,i laudable pride ‘o express our sense of this
injury, let us take heed that we do not blame
w here praise is clue.
What would we think of a man who would
a!n se an amiable wife, because a vagabond
in the street had broken the windows of his
dwelling? Equally unfeeling and under the in
fluence of theii passions are those men, who,
on every insult we receive from a loreign na
tion, si c vociferous against the President of the
United States. I will most unequivocally ex
pressmy full abhorrence of the insolence and
injustice of the British navy towards the Ame
rican comment, ai.d deeply i egret that policy,
not tie want of powei. pi events the immediate
excitation of the Jaw of retaliation in kind.
That day, my fellow-citizens, is not yetariived ;
but Itt those men know, that their total disie
gardof justice will hasten the appioach of venge
ance, when their innumerable foul deeds shall
meet with an ample lecompence. V\ lien seve
tal great objects present themselves to tlie
view of a government or an individual, the
most important will of course receive the ear
liest attention. This has been the conduct of
the President of the United States, in the faith
lui aisi barge of his executive trust. The rea
son why the ports and harbors of the United
States aie not fully fortified, is not because
Jefitrson is opposed to the most ample defence,
hut because Ins supeiior wisdom selected the
inobUiiqiortant duties for his earliest attention.
W'hui Jefferson first came into office, he found
the g*veriiinent in tk.t confusion and terror
vi in, me suits from the want of collect princi
ples wd talents; the existence ol which alarm
ed the nation, and caused them to transfer their
concerns nv.o the hands of men whose senti
ments on government were congenial vnh
their own, and ot w hose integrity they had tlie
most unquestionable proof.
’1 ic first duty ot government is to promote
tlie cbrnestic happiness ot the nation, anu to
this jjrand object die republicans fi st directed
their attention. And here, permit me to say,
in tht plainest terms, that the cordial poticy ol
the Alneiicati republic is materially different
from tfiat of the kings of Europe—the former
is, to educate the arts of peace—tiie latter, the
arts of war. It has generally been the poii, y
of European governments to pay the inmost
attention to their foreign relations, w hile they
have ihamefuny neglected the condition of their
subjects at home. Kmgs have always been
vain of the admiration of foreign courts, and in
proportion as they have succeeded in this ob
ject, they have impoverished by taxation the
people they govern. \V hat comfort will it af
torit to the millions of starving wi etches in Eu
rope to hear that their great monarch, by his
immense armies, has dethroned kings of devas
tated empties; or that his fleets have destroyed
the navy ol a rival nation. I giant, it inay llat
tet the too.ish pride of some, while it encreases
the nuseiv of me more reflecting, as, in these
splendid displays of regal giory they have fresh
eviuence of the power of their oppressors.
Republicans—plain common sense republi
cans, we have not so learned the sciem e oi go
vernment. We think the true way to com
mand iexpert abroad is to be happy and pros
perous at home, foreign nations then feel our
independence and supc.iority; and though
thev may and have insulted us, beyond a cer
tain point they durst no go. VV hen the fede
ralists were in power, they increased the na
tional <febt to an enormous amount, and this
evil was increasing in rapid progression—
when the republicans succeeded, they resolved
to destroy this devourer of the people’s sub
stance, believing the exis ence of a national
and bt the parent of all national calamity. Os
this they have not, and l hope wilt not lose
sight, until the last cent is paid off. Tne tax
es, and many impositions of the former admin
istration were removed in a short time, but to
remove the national debt is the work of 10 years
to come. It wilt be asked, are we to be expos
ed to the piiacy of Britain and France until our
national debt is entirely paid off? I answer, no
—a parti and noil-importation act, operating
on the offending nation, together with a gradu
al improvement of our fortifi, ations are the
great objects which should engage the atten
tion of our government, and will, I believe,
check the insufferable insolence of Britain.
When tbc national debt is puiimiistiefl, we
shall jxissess the most ample means for the
most ample defence, and this without the least
possible burthen on the nation. It shall grow
out of our prosperity as the apples grow on
our trees, or the grass on our ground.
Before 1 close this paper, I will express my
most unqualified approbation of the sentiments
and conduct of the President, in relation to fo
reign nations. and my undimiiiished confidence
in the wisdom of his luture measures—that
thev will be dignified, spirited mil yet mode
rate—that they will be such as to stifle the
breath of calumny, a id receive the approba
tion of American republicans and a discerning
world. FRANKLIN.
A member of the legislature of Massachu
setts has offered a bill to enforce the punctual
payment of hills at the several banks ; which
was read a first lime and committed. It is said
the bill contemplates the infliction of a penalty
of five per cent, on any sum presented at the
bank for specie, for every period of 12 hours,
which shall elapse between the time of pre
senting the said bills, and their anal payment.
VIENNA, March 38.
As scon as tne English fleet I artived be
fore Constantinople, vice acmiral Duckworth
dispatched two last sailing cuttcis n to tne
L’atk Se..—probably to inform the Russian
fleet, which lay at the mouth of the Dinan near
kilia, of his arrival. As all the strong castles
on the coast of Asia, all along the channel, aie
in the possession of the Turks, and cannot be
taken but by regular sieges ; for which the
English have not a sufficiency of troops—the
English fleet is in a very ciitical situation, for
the Turkish garrisons of these casties, amongst
whom theic are certainly a great number of
Frenchmen, might take into their hera.s to the
red-hot bulls upon the EnglLh ships as they
pass by.
BRESLAW, April 9.
On the afternoon ot the 4 h inst. a party of
200 infantry and 20 cavalry, diew off from
Clratz, and diicctcrt their march towards the
village of Fetiovv etz, for the putpose of piocur
ing provisions. General Lefebvre immediate
ly fell ujion them in the evening, and soon o
biiged them to retreat to the fort ; besides the
killed, the enemy lost one hussar officer, ten
mounted hussars and six fusileers.
BAMBERG, Ap.il 10.
Direct information from the French head
quarters, dated Posin, March 21, confirms irotn
an unquestionable source, the previous rum
ours respecting overtures making between the
belligerent forces, and further states, that a
continental peace will, without doubt, be the
result.
HAGUE, April 14.
The rew loan is already completed and
subscriptions can only be had at second hand
Accounts from London state, that 120.000 *
pound*- sterling has been shipped on beard two
armed vessels destined for the Baltic. The
allies of Great-Britain, according to the dis
patches of lotd Hutchinson, appear to stand in
great need ot this subsidy. There is also a
great scarcity of arms.
LOWER ELBE, April 16.
The Swedes have taken possession of the
fort of Swineniude, by the aid of gun boats
Marshal Mortier, with a considerable corps,
attacked the garrison at Stralsund, which he
probably has, by this time, obliged to take
shelter in the fortress. Last night, or the
night before, the whole body of foreign troops
(the Geusbarmen excepted) marched out of
Hamburgh. The posts in the citv and the gates
are now supplied by the city soldiers.
The garrison at Dantzic is from day to day
reinfoiced. Eleven thousand men ate to em
bark for that place from Memel.
The rumour ot a determined armistice, and
faint appearance of peace lias completely van
ished away The prince ofßenevento ilissaid
is shortly going to Berlin.
PARI s ), April 10.
By an imperial decree of the 20th of March,
the establishment of five legions of reserve for
the interior, and foi the protection of the fron
tiers and the sea coast, is ordered. Each le
gion is to consist of five battalions, ch battal
ion of eignt companies, and each company of
160 men. Each legion is to be commanded
by a senator, and receives but one standard or
eagle—their uniform is to be the same as that
of the line.
The first legion meet at Lisle, the second at
Mentz, the third at Rennes, the fourth at Ver
sailles and the fifth at Grenoble.
By two impei ial decrees, the fortifications u{
Brest and Antwerp have been declared in a
state of siege, and the senator Abboville has
been appointed governor of Brest, and the sen
atftr Feiino governor of Antwerp; both have
the command of sea and land troops, and tike
vvisc of the national guards, and they have ex
clusively the direction of the police of the city
where they command.
The inspector-general of the military hospi
tals, Mr. Desgenetier has received orders to go
to the grand army.
HAMBURGH, April 19.
Letters from Memel, dated the 2d of April,
mention the arrival there of the Emperor of
Russia. Their majes ies the Empeior of Rus
sia and the king of Prussia, a few days after,
intended to repair to the army. A Prussian
corps is embarking at Memel for Dantzic.
It is not mere report that Spanish troops ate
i pon the march towards the Elbe. 1 hey are
actually to ‘ in 15,000 French ttoops that ate
now gathering along the Rhine.
FROM LATE LONDON PAPERS.
Lord Hutchinson sent home with his last
dispatches, a part of one of the French Eagles
tstandaids) taken in the desj)erate action ot Ey
lau. It is numbered on each side “44.” This
trophy was accompanied by a medal of the
French order, which was taken by a Russian
from a French officer of distinction, whom he
found dead on the field of battle. It was sus
pended front the button hole of the coat by a
crimson ribbon, and is about the size of a half
crown piece. On one side is the head of Bo
naparte in gold, encircled with the words, “ Na
poleon entp. des Frampix,” and on the other,
a corresponding medalion with the inscrip
tion “ L’Hotvneur de la Patrie.”
The medal of the French order of merit,
which, with a part of one of the enemy’s Ea
gles, have reached London, (and which we
have already described.) were sent home by
Sir Robert Wilson, who was present at the
memorable battle of Eylau.
A war contribution of a million, has been
imposed ou the city of Berlin.