Newspaper Page Text
Lommentary
BLACKONOMICS By James Clingman
Chasing the illusion of equality
“Seemingly, our biggest
objective is to be equal, but this
is not the answer to our issues.
The problem is that they want
to keep us striving to be equal
to take our minds off of the
real problems, and if we never
discover the real problem, they
can keep the control and keep
us right where they want us.”
This quote was taken from an
e-mail I received from Celeste
Wakely, a member of the
Blackonomics Million Dollar
Club (BMDC), regarding
knowing our history and act
ing upon that knowledge. She
stressed the importance of
using what we know about
economics to elevate ourselves
rather than spending all of our
money to elevate others. Her
assessment of our continued
quest for “equality” hits the
mark.
What does this “equality”
thing mean to black folks any
way? The National Urban
League boasts of an “Equality
Index” that shows us what we
already know: That black folks
are still behind whites in eco
nomic terms as well as other
areas. Well, that’s been in force
GUEST COMMENTARY By Bill Fletcher Jr.
Competing interests?
I recently attended an
event concerning HIV/
AIDS where a representa
tive of the Washington,
D.C. Mayor Anthony
Williams mentioned in
passing that $1 million
from the federal Centers
for Disease Control and
Prevention had been cut
from contributions to the
District of Columbia. He
indicated that “compet
ing interests” led to the
loss of the funds.
What immediately came
to mind was the question
of what could those com
peting interests have
been? The $1 million was
to be used for HIV/AIDS
prevention work target
ing young people. What
is more important than
preventing the spread of
the pandemic?
“Competing interests”
is a very nice way of say
ing that funds that should
be in the federal budget
for social services are not
there. They are not there
because of political deci
sions made by this
administration. These
political decisions
demonstrate, once again,
thet: the isye of
HIV/AIDS is as much a
political issue as it is a
medical issue.
One million dollars cut
from the D.C
HIV/AIDS budget, yet
billions spent on the ille
gal war in Iraq. One mil
lion cut from the D.C.
HIV/AIDS budget, yet
the administration
believed that it was fiscal
ly sound to offer a tax cut
to the wealthiest portions
of the population.
t, this situation fur
mtes is that
since we came to this country.
Whites had an affirmative
action program that entitled
them to everything and enti
tled blacks to nothing. For
years the Urban e has
also published a \];:% col
umn from its president titled
1o Be Equal. 1 don't know what
it means, but that’s the title; it
sounds like an aspiration, a
goal, or a petition of some
kind.
As Celeste says, we keep
chasing “equality” with
absolutely no chance whatso
ever to attain such a lofty ideal,
while other groups never even
mention being “equal” with
white folks. They just come to
this country and get busy mak
ing money by starting busi
nesses and capturing segments
of industry, especially in which
black folks spend millions of
dollars.
White people go about their
business, handing out tokens
of appreciation for our loyalty
every now and then, sponsor
ing all the entertainment we
can stand, with the ultimate
goal of cutting off all rational
communication among blacks
the crisis in social services
and assistance is not the
result of the absence of
funds, but rather that
funds are not being allo
cated in a manner that
addresses the common
interests. The fact that
D.C. has to suffer under
such cuts is illustrative of
the decisions that have
been taking place since
the early days of the Rea
gan administration to
strangle the public sector,
and so limit its funds that
there exists no room to
maneuver. Social pro
grams to benefit the pub
lic are cut in the name of
putting funds into the
pockets of the rich. This
approach failed in the
1980 s, and it is failing
again.
Now, however, we are
talking about cuts that
are going to the bone.
Not only are these cuts
taking place, but further
administrative restric
tions are being placed on
the usage of funds.
Whether in the U.S.A. or
overseas, .money to
address HIV/AIDS is
being hamstrung by
restrictions on the ability
to discuss sexuality and
condom usage. Such
straight-jacketing effec
tively means that the bulk
of HIV/AIDS education
becomes irrelevant, par
ticularly to sexually active
youth. Thus, “competing
interests” becomes a ques
tion not so much about
which programs will
receive funding, but
rather whether people
will live, or whether they
will die.
In an atmosphere of on
going tension over
and by keeping our attention
focused on anything that has
do with singin,” rappin,” danc
ing,’ and tellin’ jokes about one
another. Oh yes, they want us
to concentrate on playin’
games, jumpin’ real high in
those new gym shoes, drivin’
shiny cars and trucks, and
drinkin’ soda pop and liquor,
too. They want us to keep
stylin' and chillin' and dont
forget about the killin, y all.
All of this negative, mean
ingless, and diversionary
behavior, as black people go
about the business we feel is
really important: Gaining
equality. Youd think we would
know by now that equality is
nothing more than a nirvana
pipedream that will never be
realized. Even more impor
tandy, black people in America
should put the quest for equal
ity on the shelf, pernanently,
and get busy on a quest for
economic empowerment.
Whites own and control the
vast majority of the resources
of this country. As the Urban
League annual report points
out — every year — there are
widening gaps between blacks
whether and/or when the
next terrorist attack
will/may transpire, the
HIV/AIDS pandemic
destroys more lives than
Al Qaeda could ever
dream of destroying. Yet,
this fact is regularly
obscured each time the
terror alerts are raised and
we are told that a new,
potential terrorist has
been identified, become
the source of speculation,
or apprehended.
“Competing interests”
means, as well, that while
Africa, Asia, the
Caribbean and Latin
America should be receiv
ing substantial aid to
confront not oaly
HIV/AIDS, along with
other illnesses, poverty,
lack of jobs, and environ
mental degradation, this
administration sees fit to
plow more money into its
illegal occupation of Iraq,
the creation of more mili
tary hardware, and the
further militarization of
Third World countries,
all in the name of fight
ing terrorism.
Go figure.
Bill Fletcher ]r. is presi
dent of Trans Africa Forum,
a Washington, D.C.-based
non-profit educational and
organizing center formed
to raise awareness in the
United States about issues
facing the nations and peo
ples of Africa, the
Caribbean and Latin
America. He also is co
chair of the anti-war coali
tion, United for Peace and
Justice (www.unitedfor
peace.org). He can be
reached at bfletcher@
transafricaforum.org.
AUGUSTA FOCUS
and whites when it comes to
family net worth, wages and
employment, home owner
ship, criminal justice, bank
loans, and the list goes on and
on. Yet, we chase “equality.”
Whites claim “reverse” dis
crimination and graciously
allow blacks to be “economi
cally included” in taxpayer
funded projects. Yet, we chase
“equality.” Whites treat black
life with irreverence and kill us
for reaching for cell phones. (Is
that why we kill one another so
easily and in record numbers?
Trying to be equal with them?)
Yet, we chase “equality.”
Whites run the political sys
tem, the economic system, the
social system, the educational,
and the legal system. Do we
really believe they are about to
help black people To Be Equal
with them? How naive are we?
Or, maybe it's a question of
how lazy we are. We should be
doing the things that a nation
within a nation does to devel
op and maintain its own eco
nomic foundation. You know,
like the Vietnamese who went
to what used to be called West
minster, Calif, which is now
GUEST COMMENTARY By Ron Walters
Blackberrys but few blacks
If someone shows up on
your door step with a Palm
Pilot or a Blaecpi(bcrry in hand
and youre not registered to
vote and they ask you to do so,
by all means comply. But it
should be of some note who or
what organizations sent the
canvasser to your door.
In the purest sense, no one
actually “controls” the black
vote, but it has been the task of
black leadership historically to
ide, manage, cajole and per
g:dc blacks to vo,tc, bascxrzrn
our own history of s e for
civil rights and soleufiticc,
and our own knowledge of
what we want from the politi
cal system.
What has happened in this
political season is that there is a
new kind of organization on
the scene called a “527,”a ref
erence to a particular section
of the Internal Revenue Ser
vice code. They fit a so-called
loophole in the McCain-Fein
gold campaign finance law
that lets nonpartisan organiza
tion raise money for voter
mobilization in unlimited
amounts. Most of them are
oriented toward the Democra
tic Party, and have raised hun
dreds of millions of dollars
from organized labor, the
Internet, some corporations
and from other sources like
special events featuring enter
tainers.
The problem is that most of
these organizations are not
headed by blacks and litde of
the money has found its way
into blaz organizations. In
fact, the empire that has been
created is run by Steve Rosen
thal, of America Coming
Together (ACT). It influences
a coalition of these organiza
tions through its control of
nearly $l5O million and the
ability to convince funders
that Rom“edd\al can identify
unregist voters, ter
them and turn them ov.:f?:otc
effectively than black leader
ship can.
'Fhis charge, as the basis
upon Rosenthal has raised
millions of dollars, is patentdy
false. In the 2000 election
cyde, black voters effectively
called “Litde Saigon;” In case
you Sistahs havent noticed,
they control the nail industry
now.
But there is some good news
on the black front. Have you
heard about the project in
Detroit? 1 am told the City
Council voted 7-2 to bring in
Claud Anderson and his Pow
ernomics business develop
ment program. Its a drop in
the bucket at S3O million, but
it is a start and could be the
precursor for many other ini
tiatives across this country for
black people.
It is also a great example of
nation-building. After all,
Detroits population is over
whelmingly black, isnt i? (I
also heard that the celebrated
young black Mayor of Detroit
made an unsuccessful attempt
to stop the project. Is that true,
Detroiters? Why?)
All things not being equal,
chasing the illusion of equality
and trying “to be equal” with
white folks is an exercise in
futility and keeps our attention
diverted from other much
more important issues for
black people in this country.
mn:Eht up with white voters in
both registration and turnout.
Census data shows that the
difference between blacks and
whites in Voter Registration
was only two percent, while
the difference in turnout was
only 2.3 percent. Moreover, if
gou take the 1 to 2 million
lack ballots that were thrown
out in 2000, the black voting
rate pmbabnz' exceeded white
voting overall.
The point here is that this
was not accomplished by Palm
Pilots and Blackberrys or Steve
Rosenthal, but by the infra
structure put together by such
groups as the National Coali
tion on Black Civic Participa
tion, the black L&dersgiap
Forum, The NAACP the
National Rainbow/Push
Coalition and other organiza
tons. In addition, the mes
sages and information on
voter mobilization was trans
mitted to the black communi
ty by black television and
radio, principally through
people such as Bob Johnson,
Tom Joyner and Tavis Smiley,
but recendy by Russell Sim
mons who has brought in an
important Hip-Hop genera
tion to voting. That infrastruc
ture has been starved by the
new set-up because the tradi
tional funders have bought the
yokey doke. A few months
ago, Russell Simmons crashed
a MoveOn meeting in New
York to protest their ignoring
his proposals.
This is serious stuff. In one
sense, whatever force is per
ceived to be in control otPtic
black vote has political influ
ence with money people and
policy makers, so the inter
vention of the Rosenthal
crowd is not just about vot
but about WLO is pcrcciv:int%
control black political power -
mdwh%mmfldowMfimm.
Aware of this, it is surprisi
to me that he has becurrxpass::tl§
ed by some members of the
Co ional Black Caucus
who m used histhmo:ixr‘sos to
register voters in their districts
- without demanding that
black organizations should be
August 26, 2004
Since we will continue to
measure everything when it
comes to €CONOMICs among
various demographic groups
and consumer segments, when
we compare blacks to whites,
or even when we compare
blacks to the progress we
should have made by now,
maybe “parity” is a better
word.
James E. Clingman, an
adjunct professor at the Universi
ty of Cincinnatis African Amer
ican Studies department, is for
mer editor of the Cincinnati
Herald Newspaper and founder
of the Greater Cincinnati
African American Chamber of
Commerce. He hosts the radio
program, “Blackonomics,” and
has written several books, includ
ing: Economic Empowerment or
Economic Enslavement - We
have a Choice; Blackonomics;
and the recently published
Black-o-Knowledge-Stuff we
need to know. Clingman's books
are available at his website,
www.blackonomics.com. - He
can be contacted theve or by tele
phone at (513) 489-4132.
funded to do the work.
You might even be able to
make the case that it doesn'
matter who is in control of the
black vote because the agenda
is the same. It isn't. Look at
any survey and there are strik
ing differences in the strength
of black and white opinions
on most issues and in their
priorities given to certain
issues. So, f the MoveOn.org,
ACT crowd has the money,
they also control the message.
This new bid for control of
the black vote by those out
side of the black community -
whether it is up front or not,
challenges the black commu
nity t:iavc its own plan. But
working it requires that we
have our own money. Blacks
who have money -the Cosby,
Oprah crowd - not only don't
give enough and don' give it
to other black organizations,
some, such as Baby Face
Edmonds are raising money
for ACT rather than for black
organizations. Maybe Baby
Face hasn't been asked. Well,
that has to change. The black
political infrastructure has to
raise its own money.
The bottom line serious point
in this is that if the black polit
ical infrastructure continues
to be starved, John Kerry
could loose this election. So
far, less than $lO million has
come into the black commu
nity, when blacks constitute
nearly 20 percet of the voting
base of the Democratic Party
and 50 percent in some key
states. Democratic victory in
this election, like all others, is
dependent upon black voter
turnout and it cant be done
by Palm Pilots and Blackber
rys, but by the cultural leader
ship of our community.
Ron Walsers is the Distin
guished Leadership Scholar,
director ”Z;‘dx African Ameri
can Leadership Institute in the
Academy of Leadership and
professor of government and pol
itics at the University of Mary
landrCofl%’:ark. His latest
book is te Nationalism,
Black Interests” (Wayne State
University Press).
9A