The Georgia bulletin (Atlanta) 1963-current, November 19, 1964, Image 5
SPOTLIGHT ON SOCIAL REFORM
What Is A Socialist?
Saints in Black and White
ST. GERTRUDE 125
• Father Mayhew’s column will be resumed
after his return to the Archdiocese from vaca
tion.
BY WILLIAM J. SMFTH , S.J.
There is a sentence in the encyclical of Pius XI
on "Reconstruction of the Social Order" which,
through misunderstanding or misinterpretation,
has caused untold harm to both Christian and
civic unity in this country.
The sentence reads: "No one can be at the
-same time a sincere Catholic
and a true Socialist," The im
portant word in that sentence
is the adjective true.
THOSE WHO use that papal
pronouncement as a weapon to
indict others for "softness to-
[ ward Communism" usually as-
sume that "socialization" as we
'know it in America must be
Identified with true Socialism,
The fallacious reasoning could be put in the form
of a syllogism that would read:
"No one can be at the same time a sincere
Catholic and a true Socialist,"
But, social legislation is true Socialism.
THEREFORE, anyone who supports social leg
islation cannot be at the same time a sincere
Catholic.
The false reasoners go on to state that this
thing which they call Socialism leads to Commu
nism and therefore the so-called 'liberal Catho
lic" is a tool, wittingly or unwittingly, of the
Communist conspiracy.
The simple fact is that the true Socialism, to
which Pius XI referred in his time, hardly exists
in this country today. You will find it in some of the
weak, but articulate Socialist Parties which are
hardly much more than a name on the ballot in
the voting booth. Or perhaps among some of the
Trotskyite groups. They still advocate complete
destruction of the right to private property, the
placing of the total means of production in the
hands of the government, the class struggle and an
end to capitalism.
At least ten years ago, however, the Interna
tional Convention of world-wide Socialist Parties
had so modified their basic tenets that a true
Socialist of the time of Pius XI would not have
recognized the child of the parent. In this coun
try most of the leaders of "Socialism", while
they still have a nostaglic affection for the old
term "Socialism", should be more properly
characterized as "Public Welfarists".
IRONICALLY enough, in practically every coun
try in the world, especially among the trade union
ists, the most aggressive, the most effective anti
communists are to be found in the ranks of those
who still like to call themselves Socialists.
Commenting on the changes in Socialism, even
in his own day, Pius XI in his social encyclical
remarked, "Class warfare, provided it abstains
from enmities and mutual hatred, is changing
gradually to an honest discussion of differences,
based upon the desire of social justice. If this is
by no means the blessed social peace which we all
long for, it can be and must be an approach to
wards the mutual cooperation of vocational groups.
The war declared against private ownership has
also abated more and more. In such a way that
nowadays it is not really the possession of the
means of production which is attacked but that type
of social rulership, which, in violation of all
justice, has been seized and unsurped by the
owners of wealth. This rulership in fact belongs
not to the individual owners but to the State.
' If these changes continue, it may well come
about that gradually the tenets of mitigated So
cialism will no longer be different from the pro
gram of those who seek to reform human society
according to Christian principles."
HAVE WE NOT seen in our own day this hope
of Pius XI fulfilled in many ways? Advocates of
varying political beliefs, of differing religious
creeds, are seen uniting in common cause for the
enactment of needed social legislation for the
cultural, social and economic betterment of the
poor and the needy.
Through every papal encyclical on the social
order runs the theme of the right and duty of
the State to promote the Common Good. Pope
John XXIII amplifying Catholic social doctrine de
clared it the duty of the State, taking proper
precautions of prudence, to protect, where nec
essary the rights of the citizens to opportunities
for employment, to the preservation of health,
education, welfare benefits for the aged-in a word
what we today call social security.
Argue, if you will, as to the practical means of
attaining any and all welfare programs that might
be proposed. But the principle is clear. The State
has the right and the duty to promote the Common
Good and when necessary to intervene directly in
the economic and social lives of the citizens. No
Catholic may be called insincere or socialistic
who cooperates with his fellow citizens, regard
less of race, creed or color, in supporting social
legislative measures when the facts of life clearly
reveal the need.
NEW PRESIDENT of the National Council of Catholic Women is Mrs. Marcus Kilch
(left) of Youngstown, Ohio, shown here with the retiring president, Mrs. Joseph McCarthy
of San Francisco (center) and Miss Margaret Mealey, executive director ‘of N.C.C.W.
AFRICAN LESSON
Your World And Mine
CONTINUED FROM PAGE 4
substantially complete and a new equilibrium al
ready established on the continent. The African
view is very different. The freedom of All Africans
is in jeopardy while one remains in bondage,
WHETHER THE liquidation of colonialism re
quires the physical withdrawal of the whites, some
of whom are settled in Africa for centuries, is a
question which Africans consider these whites
themselves must answer. What is clear in the
minds and intentions of black Africans is that
political and economic domination by whites mino
rities must end where it survives, and that social
discrimination by whites must end everywhere.
This objective has been attained in the recently
freed countries. It is proceeding in Northern
Rhodesia and in the remaining British colonies of
Bechuanaland, Basutoland and Swaziland, all of
which are moving rapidly towards self-govern
ment. The issue remains, nevertheless, in a vast
region in the south of the continent, in Portu
guese-held Angola and Mozambique, in the self-
governing British possession of Southern Rho
desia, and in both the Republic of South Africa
and the trust territory of South-West Africa which
it administers,
THE INDEPENDENT states of black Africa and
the Arab League states of North Africa encourage
independence movements in all these territories.
They know very well, however, that South Africa's
economic and military power is overwhelmingly
THURSDAY, NOVEMBER 19, 1964 GEORGIA BULLETIN PAGE 5
NUNS FROM INDIA
6 Sari Sisters 9 Steal Show
At Womens 9 Convention
V
74
71
!
fr
I
FT
J
ACROSS
1 She became one
4 She was known for
her—— of the Pas
sion
8 adder
11 not women
14 upward
15 long time
16 python
17 expert
18 container
19 fan’s stick
20 part of a headdress
21 frequently used
Catholic symbol
22 Biblical character
24 Greek township
26 uniform In color
27 Injury
30 ordinary
33 mark of disgrace
36 watertight
40 churlish
43 used at funerals
45 part of the eye
46 ancient Roman
dates
48 not the clergy
50 sub
51 church courts
53 Malayan tree
65 red
56 Family name of an
American foundress
of a religious order
for women
58 challenged
60 Indefinite article
(Fr.)
61 substance found in
blood serum
63 Australian novel
ist’s maiden name
65 Abyssinian measure
of weight
67 Her is also a
canonized saint
71 sustain
74 to enlarge a hole
77 patient
78 French verb
79 month In which
her feast occurs
81 flabby
84 route
85 designates maiden
name
86 animal
87 scold severely
88 ivy thicket
89 Libyan measure
90 Order of the
Eastern Star
91 woman’s name
92 without surviving
Issue (Latin)
DOWN
1 Province of So.
Africa
2 bind
3 ninth day before
the Ides
4 scientist’s refuge
5 above
6 not binding
7 nine (comb, form)
8 She was one
9 coin
10 Greek god
11 armor
12 sound again
13 snug abode
23 Eve’s origin
25 amplification factor
26 She was In
Latin
28 planet
29 part of digit
31 Japanese verse
32 abode of dead
(Egypt.)
34 trim
35 removed moisture
37 having knobs •
38 to call (arch)
39 gnawing animals
40 feathered verte
brates
41 pay homage to
42 hinder
44 rein
47 She was born in
49 growl
52 var. Of seal
54 vegetables
57 illuminated
59 the gods
62 leaf veins
64 reward of valor
(abbr)
66 concerning
68 fruit pies In Eng
land
69 obstruct
70 stalks
71 stoop
72 one who puts to
service
73 Island, New Zealand
75 grass. No. Africa
76 move In a circle
79 recent (prefix)
80 Indebted to
82 May In Paris
83 sacred vessels
ANSWER TO LAST WEEK’S PUZZLE, PAGE 7
BY FR. RALPH HARTMAN
(N.C.W.C. News Service)*
WASHINGTON — The women
who "stole the fashion show"
at the National Council of Cath
olic Women convention here
wore no mink. They were two
vivacious nuns from India who
caught the eye in blue and white
sari habits.
Sister Frances Esper and
Sister Rosemary Nampudakem
are members of the Sisters of
the Immaculate Heart, founded
in Krishnagar, near Calcutta,
India, by Texas-born Bishop
Louis L. R. Morrow 14 yegjrs
ago.
THE 184 Sisters of the dio
cesan congregation dress in the
manner of women in India. The
sari they wear is a long band
of cotton cloth which they wind
about themselves, using one
end of the cloth to make an at
tractive head covering.
They find that people, es
pecially the shy women of In
dia, come to them much more
readily when they are so dress
ed than if they wear a western-
type garment. Even with a hem
line at their feet, the Sisters
say that the sari is very prac
tical and prove the point by
showing a picture album with
photographs of sari-wearing
nuns working in medical dis
pensaries, teaching and riding
bicycles—their usual mode of
f transportation.
Sister Frances is a native of
Detroit and the only westerner
in the congregation. She and
her dark-eyed companion have
been in the United States five
ARNOLD VIEWING
Dreadfully Arty Tragedy
BY JAMES W* ARNOLD
greater than their combined strength, andthatto-
day’s major weapons must be sabotage, guerrilla
war and such world opinion as they can muster.
They are confident, nevertheless, that Portu
gal’s presence in Africa will not survive the Sa
lazar regime, and an independent Angola and Mo
zambique will represent a major advance for
them and a substantial outflanking of the remain
ing salient. They recognize that South Africa
would readily embark on a military adventure to
retain control of the labor force of these Portu
guese territories, without which their gold mines
would be in serious trouble, but they believe that
for once the West and the Soviet bloc would join
in action to prevent such a crude revival of colon
ialism.
Meanwhile, the position of the West, including
the United States, on this issue of human rights in
southern Africa will play a major part in the evo
lution of African attitudes towards us. As of now,
Africa is obsessed with a fear of what it calls
neo-colonialism. It interprets all help from the
United States and its allies as motivated by a de
sire to consolidate economic control over Africa
as a prelude to renewing political control. It sees
South Africa, Southern Rhodesia and the Portu
guese territories as the "white salient" held
for the purpose of mounting the counter-attack,
If we fail to take a clear stand on the moral is
sue, each time the question of human rights in
this region is raised at the United Nations o^else-
where, we confirm the black Africans in their
conviction.
About halfway through "Lilith," you get the
awful feeling that what you are afraid is going
to happen will happen. This will be a dread
fully arty tragedy, and you’re not going to care,
and you’re not going to know much more about
human life than when you started.
Perhaps something could have been made of
this complex story about a young sanitarium
attendant who falls in love with a pretty schizo
phrenic patient. (The moddy tale is from J. R.
Salamanca’s moody 1961 novel). Producer-direc
tor Robert Rossen (last film: "The Hustler")
uses every poetic device known to film to make
it seem profound and important. It's unquestion
ably more fun to watch what
Rossen is doing and ignore the
characters.
BUT WHAT we get, ultimate
ly, is an over-wrought varia
tion on the girls-are-no-darn-
good theme. The patient (Jean
Sebrg) turns out to be mad in
the medieval sense; evil, pos
sessed, a sort of Section Eight
Lucretia Borgia. She is apparently Intended to be
a figurative incarnation of Lilith, the female
vampire of Jewish folklore, the corrupter of chil
dren, who uses sexual desire to lure humans to
their destruction.
The hero (Warren Beatty) makes a simple
mistake. He insists on being the exclusive
victim of this unearthly charm. When she stub
bornly spreads its around to others of all ages
and sexes, he becomes jealous and precipita
tes multiple disaster. In the end, he seems to
achieve moral regeneration by realizing the
ture nature of her madness.
At least that is one interpretation. Another
(shades of "Dr. Caligari") is that it is all Beat
ty’s mad dream, an approach that would raise
intriguing questions about the bourndaries be
tween sanity and insanity, good and evil. It
would also help explain the film’s misty dream
like quality and the murky demonic implica
tions not really needed in the first interpreta
tion, where the point seems simply that mad
ness can be attractive but that we approach it at
our peril.
MY UNCLE HAROLD, being blunt and uncom
plicated, will object, of course, that this is in
any case just another psycho-ward-and-sex film,
that these are not the kind of people who live
next door (at least as they can be observed
through the kitchen window), and that it is all
irrelevant to life as usually lived.
In truth, this is an era when film-makers are
more interested in female demons than female
humans. (The story has a decidedly sick view
of women, whether it is the author’s or meant
to be the hero's. Of the other three main female
characters, one is cold and sexless, one is pe
culiar, and the other, married to a boor, attempts
to seduce Beatty, who seems to spend most of
his film career fending off predatory women).
If the heroine is a demon, we can, goody goody,
have all kinds of sin scenes, healthy, unheal
thy and uncategorizable.
This is not to criticize the motives or taste
weeks hoping to spread the news
of their charitable apostolate
among the poor of India by
speaking to women's groups.
Asked how long they intend to
stay. Sister Frances said,
* Well leave that up to the Holy
Spirit."
FOR those who tire of speak
ing in English (which she man
ages with British perfection),
Sister Rosemary is prepared to
discourse in Malayalam, the
vernacular language of the In
dian liturgy in her area, or in
Hindi or Bengali.
Even ancient Syriac comes
into the discussion when Sis
ter Rosemary is asked if other
members of her family are
Catholic, Without a moment's
hesitation she replies that her
family has been Catholic from
the time that the Apostle St.
Thomas evangelized India. The
Syro-Malabar liturgy of India
is so ancient that is an argu
ment that the Faith was brought
to India at least by the third
century.
Sister Rosemary demonstrat
ed the characters of the lan
guage by writing on a black
board, "May Jesus the Mes
siah be praised." This is the
usual greeting among Catholics
in her homeland, she explained,
just as Americans say hello.
Use of the title, Messiah, is al
so proof of the ancient tradi
tion of Catholic life in the East.
SISTER Frances gave some
sidelights on the forthcoming
Eucharistic Congress in Bom
bay, which Pope Paul will at
tend. She said all the Catholics
of India have been praying and
making sacrifices for its suc
cess for the past year. Dele
gates will come, she said, from
every corner of the vast country
of over 450 million people. Even
the poorest have made contribu
tions to pay for the congress,
she said.
Sister Frances decided to
give up her work as a budding
journalist and secretary of a
real estate broker in Detroit to
work as a Sister among India's
masses after meeting Bishop
Morrow.
The "Sari Sisters" also
expressed gratitude to the dele
gates of the convention of the
National Council of Catholic
Women for Madonna Plan aid,
assisted by Catholic Relief Sei>
vices—National Catholic Wel
fare Conference. The Sisters
receive $100 per month to help
them care for poor children.
The Sisters are staying in the
U.S. at Dunbarton College of
Holy Cross here.
. .xmMbmkS
HOST — Valerian Cardinal
Gracias, Archbishop of Bom
bay, will welcome Pope Paul
VI and thousands of the
faithful from around the
world to the 38th Interna
tional Eucharistic Congress,
to be held in Bombay from
Nov. 28 to Dec. 6.
of Rossen, long one of my favorite directors
("Walk in the Sun," "All the King’s Men").
The several sex sequences are impeccable and
among the most lyrical in a lyrical movie.
But lyrical movie. But lyrical or clumsy, they
are bound to keep an audience awake and its
mind off popcorn.
ROSSEN HAS clearly let himself go on "Lil
ith." He had photographed it in superb,
fresh locations (the Great Falls area of the Pot-
tomac in Maryland, the 18-room Oyster Bay
mansion-estate of a Brooklyn banker). He uses
Befgmanesque forest and fog, the irridescent
waters of "Lord of the Flies," the reflected-
pond beauties of "Sundays and Cybele."
He works the slow fade (one scene, more or
less interminably, melts into another) as it has
seldom been worked before. He uses .sound creat
ively, sometimes turning up natural sound for
effect (the town band downs out everything dur
ing a fair sequence), sometimes exphasizing a
dramatic or rhythmic element (a clock ticking,
ping pong balls bouncing, pool balls clicking).
Most closeup camera setups are contrived so
that at least two actors are in the frame, us
ually the speaker and a third party reacting
in the background. The cutting is often beauti
ful; the montage of shots at the country fair
jousting tournament is one obvious example.
The trouble is that the film's point is either
too obscure or too shallow to be worth such
a pretentious production. Rossen slights an essen
tial; one has to give a hang about the charac
ters, even become emotionally involved with them.
If it can't be with the girl, who is both insane
and wicked, it must be with the boy.
BUT BEATTY plays him like all the others
he has played: surly, slouching, intense, close
mouthed, insolent-eyed. His idealism and innoce
nce should contrast with Lilith, but he comes
off as the town cut-up killing time until his mo
torcycle is fixed.
Miss Seberg is the country girl from Iowa
who flopped as St. Joan and went on to success
as a "perverse ingenue in French New Wave
movies." Here she is attractive enough and even
perverse, but has not more an air of real moral
decay than the cheerleaders at Des Moines Cen
tral High School.
Ah well, rack up points for Peter Fonda, whose
image of tennis-shoed male innocence is flaw
less; Kim Hunter, a fine actress who is asked
to contribute little more than raised-eyebrow
reaction shots; and Anne Meacham, whose subtle
projection of evil as a silkenly charming pat
ient is what everyone else was trying but didn’t
quite achieve.
CURRENT RECOMMENDED FILMS:
Superior: Behold a Pale Horse, Fall Safe.
For special tastes; Night of the Iguana, A Hard
Day’s Night, Four Days in November
Better than most: Topkapi, Mafioso, One Potato,
Two Potato, Fate is the Hunter.
God Love You
BY MOST REVEREND FULTON J. SHEEN
It is very difficult to convince anyone of the words of Our Lord:
"Give, anditwillbegiventoyou," The advice that the world gives
is common sense: "Keep it for yourself, and you will have it."
Though the world often cannot see it, those who have followed the
Lord’s advice have always prospered spiritually, but not neces
sarily those who hoard.
Recently this letter came to our attention: ’Twenty-two years
ago, I promised the Lord that if He would provide
work for me, I would give a tenth toward His work.
Soon I had my first job. I earned eighteen dollars
in six weeks. Gladly I placed a dollar in the offer
ing, but how the devil tempted me not to part with
the eighty cents, then with a quarter, then to with
hold a nickel. Fortunately for me, the Lord re
minded me to keep my promise, and I resolved to
give (pot cheerfully though, I admit). God had kept
His promise so I thought to do the same. Never
have I been tempted since to withhold any of the
Lord's portion. He continues to open the windows of heaven and
pour out blessings. He has increased my earning abilities twenty
times in twenty-two years. I also have increased my giving. In
stead of one-tenth, I am now giving three-tenths of my earnings.
There are many blessings in giving to the Lord, but mostly this:
Where your treasure is, there also is your heart."
The next problem is: To whom should you give the Lord’s por
tion? This is something you can decide for yourself, but always
keeping in mind the words of the Vicar of Christ: "Charity to The
Propagation of the Faith exceeds all other charities as heaven
exceeds earth and eternity, time" In other words, the best way
of remembering Our Lord, is to help extend the Faith to others.
Always keep in mind that The Society for the Propagation of the
Faith is the Holy Father's own Society. All the money that you
give to his Society goes directly to him. No distribution is made
by any bishop, or any diocesan or national director in this country.
The Vicar of Christ distributes where he sees the need to be
greatest.
"Give and it shall be given to you" is not a matter just for par
ishes and dioceses but for each individual. Think of the blessings
that HAVE been given you. In the spiritual order, if you were the
only sinner in the world Christ would have died for you alone.
Think of His mercy to you in the past and His patience with you in
the present. What have you given? How much do you love in re
turn? Enough to feed the starving, clothe those aching with
hard, dull bitterness of cold", educate a native priest so that the
poor may have the Gospel preached to them? Enough to sit down
now and mail a sacrifice to The Society for the Propagation of the
Faith, 366 Fifth Avenue, New York, N.Y. 10001?
GOD LOVE YOU to M.J.B. for $50 "In thanksgiving to Our Lord
for helping me through a tumor operation. I hope this check will
help others, so that they, too, can know God and His Love." ...to
W.S. for $5 "We are a couple, 74 and 69 years of age and not too
well, but we send this little offering for your poor to help them
a little and to thank God for all the blessings we have received,"
Do you find yourself perplexed by problem Christmas presents?
What to give a teacher, priest, nun, relative, is always difficult
to decide, A welcome gift for anyone on your list (or for yourself)
is a subscription to WORLDMISSIQN, a scholarly quarterly maga
zine of current missionary activities edited by Most Reverend
Fulton J, Sheen. Read about the frontiers of the Church in the
world today. Send only $5 for a year’s subscription to: WORLD-
MISSION, 366 Fifth Avenue, New York, N.Y. 10001,
Cut out this column, pin your sacrifice to it and mail it to Most
Reverend Fulton J. Sheen, National Director of The Society for the
Propagation of the Faith, 366 Fifth Avenue, New York, New York
10001, or to your Diocesan Director, Rev. Harold J. Rainey, P.-O
Box 12047, Northside Station, Atlanta 5, Georgia,