Southern school news. (Nashville, Tenn.) 1954-1965, February 01, 1957, Image 9
SOUTHERN SCHOOL NEWS—FEBRUARY 1957—PAGE 9
Georgia Legislature at Work on More Bills to Keep
MACON, Ga.
G eorgia's General Assembly began to
grind out more state laws designed
to maintain segregation, against a back
ground of several racial incidents over
the state.
Bills giving the governor broader
powers, permitting the Georgia Educa
tion Commission to subpoena witnesses
and protecting the pension rights of
teachers who transfer from public in
tegrated to private segregated schools
were being hastened along the legisla
tive route. But a proposal to repeal the
compulsory school attendance law was
apparently to be shelved unless deseg
regation actually began. (See “Legisla
tive Action.”)
In Atlanta, six Negro ministers who
were arrested on charges of refusing
to sit in seats assigned by a city transit
system bus driver said they welcomed a
test of Georgia’s segregation laws. (See
“Miscellaneous.”)
The introduction of measures de
signed to strengthen segregation de
fenses was the first order of business
following organization of the 1957-58
General Assembly of Georgia.
Four bills recommended by the Geor
gia Education Commission, an agency
created by the legislature to find means
of legally circumventing the U. S. Su
preme Court’s public school desegrega
tion ruling, were introduced in the
House.
The House swiftly approved three of
them and the Senate was expected by
observers to follow suit. The measures
receiving a green light in the House
would:
1) Continue retirement and pension
benefits for public school teachers who
accept employment in non-sectarian
private schools when Georgia imple
ments its “last resort” private school
plan of segregation defense.
2) Give the governor new powers and
Tennessee
(Continued From Page 8)
spoke on the moral and spiritual aspect
of the segregation question. Kershaw
said:
“The tragedy of America today is that
the well-meaning liberal has been mis
led into believing that segregation is
based on race hatred. To segregate with
mutual respect is Christian love. To
► integrate is to destroy racial differences
and therefore, in the most profound
sense, it is an expression of racial hatred
tor it has no respect for cultural and
i racial differences.”
NECESSITY DISCLAIMED
Dr. Preston Valien, a Negro, is pro
fessor of sociology at Fisk University.
He said:
If these bills demonstrate one thing,
they demonstrate that no educational
Measures are necessary for the orderly
desegregation of the public schools in
Tennessee. The legislation proposed is
e gally unconstitutional, administra-
hvely unworkable and totally unneces-
* sery. They show people struggling with
®eir consciences. They are unwilling to
™ what is wrong and they are unwill-
to do what is right.”
• He said the bill permitting voluntary
s egregation would create three types
0 schools, “one white, one for Negroes
®d one American.”
t One of the few colloquies of the hear-
*g took place when Rep. Harry Lee
*' ter of Bristol asked Valien if de
legated schools are American, “does
* , a t m ean the state of Tennessee has
^ operating un-American schools?”
w slien replied: “I wouldn’t say that
elways so but it is so since the
U j^ eme Court decision.”
th ? 6r then asked: “Do you think
bad ^ Upreme Court is a policy-setting
Hiat they determine what is
1 Sa^ Can an< ^ w h ,at is un-American?”
„ a *d Valien: “As far as the law is
^ned, yes.”
?et>i ® course °f testimony, two
• k amendments were suggested
s ‘ ren gthen” the Clement bills.
S< j?°OLFIELD’S PROPOSAL
$ c j i yMinal Court Judge Raulston
esta/?. old of Chattanooga proposed
’dent k ent a state pupil assign-
be rs t>°ard composed of seven mem-
atKj f the legislature, three senators
*° uld °“f representatives. His proposal
a Utho • ves t local school boards of any
ter lty m assigning pupils and trans-
to jj^Plete authority in this function
S$hn r ®commended state board,
for Crownover of Nashville, counsel
Goy ® federation for Constitutional
*.!£*■*, suggested a bill to cut off
bUr 0,^ to integrated schools “as
tion.” y rea l defense against integra-
permit him to promulgate and enforce
his own rules and regulations with the
force of law in integration disorders or
in any case in which the chief execu
tive believes an emergency exists.
3) Grant the Georgia Education Com
mission subpoena powers for investiga
tions.
A fourth House bill, which would re
peal the state’s compulsory school at
tendance law, remained bottled up in
committee after education officials and
several legislators expressed opposition.
Proponents argued the present law
would force white children to attend
school with Negroes in event of inte
gration.
ESTIMATE 10% DROP
Educators, estimating school attend
ance would drop 10 per cent with out
right repeal of the law, suggested com
pulsory attendance be required so long
as the schools are segregated.
Gov. Marvin Griffin said “if it can be
done constitutionally,” he would go
along with the compromise. “I just don’t
want any little old thing hanging like
they had in Clinton, Term.,” he said.
“Judge Taylor wanted the school inte
grated and then they tried to force par
ents to send their children to the in
tegrated school under the compulsory
school law.”
Although the bill to repeal the com
pulsory school attendance law was ap
parently not to be pushed by admin
istration forces, the other legislative
recommendations of the GEC received
only token opposition in the House.
PROMOTE VIEWPOINT
Another administration proposal ex
pected to gain swift legislative approval
would authorize the GEC to present
“the Georgia and southern point of
view” on racial problems relating to
education, with the state paying the
expenses.
A Senate committee approved a bill
to prohibit all interracial dancing, so
cial functions, entertainments, athletic
the education committees of both House
and Senate approved the school bills.
Two days later, the bills passed through
the House with only four dissenting
votes. And the dissenting votes were
cast on only two of the bills, the pupil
assignment and voluntary segregation
laws.
SENATE ACTS SLOWLY
Passage of the bill in the 33-member
Senate, however, was somewhat slower.
On Jan. 17, the same day the House
passed the bills, the Senate judiciary
committee recommended four of the
bills for passage but withheld action on
the fourth—the voluntary segregation
law—pending further study.
At the meeting, the senators called in
a Nashville attorney, Val Sanford, one
of the authors of the bills, and ques
tioned him on the constitutionality of
the program.
Sen. James Cummings of Cannon
County asked if it would not be wise to
insert somewhere in both the pupil
assignment and voluntary segregation
bills a sentence “clearly stating that
nothing in the proposed laws would
prevent a school system from desegre
gating should it desire to do so.” He
said he was worried about the voluntary
segregation bill’s constitutionality, and
particularly about the fact that if con
sidered along with the other bills, it
might be the cause of all being declared
unconstitutional “and leave us standing
there naked.”
PERMISSIVE FEATURE NOTED
Sanford said he did not subscribe to
their worries over the constitutionality
of the bills. He pointed out that the
pupil assignment law was “permissive
in nature” and had no binding effect
on any local school board. The same was
true of the voluntary segregation bill,
he said.
Sen. Clifford Allen of Nashville chal
lenged both bills as to their constitu
tionality and their “permissiveness.”
“What does the [assignment] bill mean
by ‘established social relationships’
other than segregation,” he asked. “This
bill would not be upheld even by the
supreme court of our own state.
SENATE VOTE
After one more meeting to consider
the voluntary segregation bill, the Sen
ate passed all five of the measures with
ease on Jan. 22. The assignment bill
received only three dissenting votes,
four were cast against the voluntary
segregation bill and one was cast against
the measure permitting school boards
to transfer pupils from one system to
another. , . , ,,
The only other major legislative pro
posal on the school issue was a resolu
tion deploring and denouncing the Su
preme Court school segregation rulings.
Fulton County’s Greatest
Challenge
’ iw-i
-Atlanta Constitution
training, games, sports or contests “and
other such activities”; and to require
separate seating, drinking water and
sanitary arrangements for members of
the white and Negro races at any enter
tainment or athletic contests where the
public is invited or may attend.
The author of the measure, Sen. Leon
E. Butts of Lumpkin, said it was de
signed to “get the Negroes out of base
ball.” Gov. Griffin said he approved Sen.
Butts’ bill.
COOK’S NAACP BILLS
Atty. Gen. Eugene Cook said he had
drafted legislation for submission to the
General Assembly which would:
1) Have the legislature designate the
NAACP as “an organization subversive
to the constitution and laws of the state
of Georgia.”
2) Create a legislative committee with
authority to investigate the internal af
fairs of such organizations as the
NAACP.
3) Call on U. S. Atty. Gen. Herbert
Brownell Jr. to place the NAACP on
This resolution, called by some the
“Tennessee Manifesto,” was introduced
in both houses on the day the Assembly
convened. The resolution was intro
duced separately in each house and
since it was not a joint resolution, its
passage by each house would require
no action by the governor.
The resolution was adopted by the
House the same day it approved the
school bills by a vote of 71 to 7.
The Senate has not acted on the
resolution.
LEGAL ACTION
Federal Judge William E. Miller has
accepted the Nashville School Board’s
proposal to desegregate city schools at
the first grade beginning next Septem
ber. He gave the board until Dec. 31 to
submit definite plans for desegregation
of the other 11 grades.
In its answer to a suit in behalf of 19
Negroes and two white children who
first sought to enter schools with white
students in 1955, the school board pro
posed the first grade integration plan as
a “good faith” attempt to comply with
the U. S. Supreme Court ruling.
The board had offered to decide by
next December what to do about segre
gation in other grades. Pending submis
sion of the complete plan, the court
withheld action on the request of the
NAACP for an injunction prohibiting
segregation in public schools of the city.
Z. Alexander Looby, Nashville attor
ney who represented the NAACP in the
case, said he would have to study Mil
ler’s opinion in detail before deciding
whether to appeal it.
Edwin Hunt, one of two attorneys for
the school board in the matter, said he
will recommend the board’s compliance
with the court order.
KNOXVILLE CASE
In Knoxville 14 Negro children filed
a petition in U. S. district court seeking
admission to two all-white secondary
and two all-white elementary schools.
The petition said the Negroes, 11 girls
and three boys, sought admission to
white schools last September but were
turned away by school authorities.
The Negroes asked the court to issue
a permanent injunction “forever re
straining and enjoining” school officials
from refusing to admit them and “other
persons similarly situated” as students
in all Knoxville public schools.
The city school board last May re
jected a plea by Negro leaders that it
desegregate Knoxville schools with the
opening of the September term. The
board referred the suit to the city law
department, saying it was “ready and
the federal subversive list
4) Ask the judiciary committee of the
U. S. House of Representatives to hold
a public hearing on civil rights meas
ures.
5) Give the governor of Georgia pow
ers similar to those employed by Gov.
LeRoy Collins of Florida in temporarily
suspending operation of city buses in
Tallahassee because of violence over
integrated seating.
Rep. David C. Jones of Worth County
introduced a bill in the House which
would deal with the integration prob
lem through migration.
Jones’ plan would establish a com
mission to give state money to send
children of “integration-minded” par
ents outside Georgia for their educa
tion. The commission would have eight
members, including three “intelligent”
Negroes.
An initial appropriation of five mil
lion dollars to finance activities of the
commission was asked by Jones.
GRIFFIN SPEECHES
Gov. Griffin touched on racial mat
ters in two speeches before joint ses
sions of the House and Senate.
In his state of the state report, the
governor promised to “protect both our
white and colored citizens in Georgia
from mob violence, abuse and unbridled
intimidation from whatever source it
may come.” He added, “As long as I am
your governor, there will be no break
down in the pattern of segregation in
this state.” This statement drew the
heaviest applause.
“No matter what any court may rule,”
said Griffin, “the Constitution of the
United States and the crystallized pub
lic sentiment of an overwhelming ma
jority of the people remains ‘the law
of the land’.”
In his annual budget message, Gov.
Griffin said, “We are determined to pre
vent any such unfortunate incidents
from taking place in Georgia like those
which have occurred in some of our
sister southern states.”
willing” to hire special lawyers, if nec
essary, to handle the case.
MEMPHIS CASE
The Sixth Circuit Court of Appeals,
sitting in Cincinnati, reversed a deci
sion by a Memphis district judge in
which he had refused to order, in ef
fect, the admission of five Negroes to
Memphis State University (formerly
Memphis State College).
In a 2 to 1 decision, the court ordered
the case sent back to District Judge Ma
rion Boyd for further action. It was one
in which Ruth Booker, Nellie Peoples,
Mardes Knowles Vanhook, Elijah Noel
and Joseph McGhee, Jr., sought an in
junction to prevent the Tennessee State
Board of Education and officials of the
university from denying them admis
sion to the school.
In his decision, given Nov. 22, 1955,
Judge Boyd denied the injunction re
quest but approved a plan proposed by
the Board of Education under which
there would be total desegregation at
the school within five years.
Circuit Court Judges Charles C.
Simons of Detroit and Florence Allen of
Cleveland voted to reverse the decision
while Judge Shackleford Miller Jr., of
Louisville, Ky., dissented.
NOT EQUIPPED
In its defense of the case, the school
board declared the University was not
equipped to admit a freshman class in
excess of 1,000 students and proposed
the five-year plan. This calls for the ad
mission of properly qualified graduate
students in September of 1955, seniors
in September 1956, juniors at the begin
ning of the next school year and sopho
mores and freshmen in successive years.
In Nashville, Atty. Gen. George F.
McCanless said he plans to seek a re
view of the decision by the U. S. Su
preme Court.
The contempt of court cases against
16 residents of Clinton and Anderson
County, originally scheduled to be heard
on Jan. 28, were postponed indefinitely.
The cases were based on charges re
sulting from disturbances at the Clinton
high school in December.
No reason was given for the post
ponement.
Addressing a meeting of the National
Newspaper Publishers Association at
Fisk University in Nashville, NAACP
attorney Thurgood Marshall stressed the
need for action at the community level
in support of public school desegrega
tion.
“We are finding that this problem is
not going to be solved in the courts
Segregation
Racial incidents were reported in sev
eral Georgia communities.
In Atlanta, six Negro ministers were
indicted by the Fulton County grand
jury on charges of refusing to occupy
seats assigned by the bus driver.
A. T. Walden of Atlanta, spokesman
for the attorneys representing the de
fendants, said they would not press for
an early trial but would wait and let the
cases come up through regular chan
nels. Georgia’s bus segregation law
would be attacked on the “overall
ground that it is in conflict with the
Supreme Court’s rulings,” Walden said.
This is the first bus integration inci
dent to come up in Georgia.
MILITIA ALERTED
Gov. Griffin reacted to the situation
by putting the state militia on a stand
by basis.
The governor said he had no specific
plan or legislative proposal to counter
the Negro move but vowed order would
be maintained in Georgia.
The bus integration case came just
prior to an Atlanta meeting of southern
Negro leaders “to spur the campaign
for integrated transportation.” About 60
Negroes from nine states attended.
The Rev. Martin Luther King Jr. of
Montgomery, Ala., was named chairman
of a permanent body formed out of the
group and predicted the completion of
bus integration all over the South before
1960.
PRESIDENT’S AID ASKED
President Eisenhower was asked in a
telegram from the group to make a
speech in a major southern city “urging
all southerners to abide by the Supreme
Court’s decision as the law of the
land.”
In another telegram to Vice President
(See GEORGIA, Page 16)
alone ... It will be solved on the com
munity level by voting and other
means,” said Marshall.
“I don’t blame the legislators. If they
can kick the Negro voters around and
get away with it, they ought to.”
Marshall told the NNPA publishers
and editors that some daily metropoli
tan newspapers have failed to report
“the good features” of desegregation. He
said no daily paper has gone to any ex
tent to report the favorable conditions
accompanying school integration in Ok
lahoma and West Virginia.
At the same meeting, W. Beverly Car
ter, publisher of the Pittsburgh Courier,
said in an interview the Negro press
feels a grave responsibility “to help re
solve the problems of racial conffict.
We feel we can best work toward this
end by not being inflammatory but by
attempting a reasonable approach and
by assuming all Americans are seriously
concerned about the problem.”
PROMISE REPRISALS
In Memphis the Ministers and Citi
zens League, a Negro organization,
promised reprisals against the Shelby
County delegation and other Tennessee
legislators who signed the “Tennessee
Manifesto.”
“Any elected member of the Tennes
see state legislature who sponsors such
circumventing legislation will be met at
the polls by concerted campaign efforts
to defeat the legislator,” the statement
said.
At a meeting in Nashville, the state
president of the Tennessee Federation
for Constitutional Government said the
NAACP wants to “turn our free schools
into federal prisons.” Addressing the ad
visory committee of the Nashville-Da-
vidson County chapter of TFCG, Donald
Davidson applauded the school segrega
tion proposals of Gov. Frank Clement
but said they do not go far enough.
COMMUNITY ACTION
Leaders of two race relations groups
in Memphis, one white and the other
Negro, expressed confidence that by
joint effort acts of violence such as seen
in other southern cities can be avoided
in Memphis.
W. W. Scott, chairman of the Greater
Memphis Race Relations Committee,
said his organization hopes to meet soon
with its Negro counterpart, the Mem
phis Committee for Progress.
In Knoxville, the Rev. Ted. R. Witt,
pastor of Lincoln Park Methodist
Church, said he and “at least half a
dozen other ministers” have been vic
tims of “abuse by anonymous telephone
callers. I suppose they are trying to si
lence us because the Knoxville Minis
terial Association has been actively sup
porting integration moves,” Witt said.