Newspaper Page Text
SOUTHERN
RECORDER.
PV GRANTLAND & OH.ME.
MILLEDGEVILLE, GEORGIA, MONDAY EVENING, FEBRUARY 20, 1&37.
Ho
riie Rkcordek Is puhlishod weekly, on
ock street, between Wayne ami Jefferson,
Dnllnrs per annum. payable in ail entice
*' 1,'"^ulillari, if not [mid before the end of the
7 1 '* ' v B f,sEMEVTs conspicuously inserted at the
J ' i rates. Those sent without n specification
U5l V* (l num ber of insertions, will be published un-
P1 ordered out, and charged accordingly.
s ‘ c,ics of land and negroes, by Xduiioistrators,
Frcca'or*, or Uuardi.uH. are required by law, to
f' on the first Tuesday in tl.c month, lie
" ^ ( | )e |,ours of ten in the forenoon and three
tothe afternooil, at tin* court-house of the conn-
111 jo which tint property is buttle.—Notices of
sale of land must he git in a public gazette
. . i, days, and negroes, font r days, previous
to ihe day of sale.
Nonce of the sale of personal property must bp
given in like manner, Foary days previous to the
d ,v of sale. Also, notice to the debtors ami crc-
aponi of an estate must be published fur Volin*
° Notice that application will lie made to the
Court of Urdinary for leave to sell land, must be
jublished for mu’* months
V
Visit |ir
All business m the line of Printing, will meet
pt attention at the Rt:<:oi;i)Kft Office.
LtrTEKJ foil Imsiness) must be post-paid.
iiougYfcsa.
SIXOND SESSION’.
* IN SENATE,
Titt'iisu iv, February 8.
GEORGIA AND THE U. STATES.
The following Message was roceivetl
from the President of the United States,
fcv his Private Secretnn :
To Semite uni House ut Representatives of Ike.
Untied States ••
Washingio.v, Mb Echruai v, ifi27.
I communicate to Congress topics of n letter
from the lioveriior of the State of Georgia, re-
ciiii'd since my Message of the 6th iust., and of
enciesuas received with it, further cuufirnia-
pve of the fact3 stated in that Message.
JOHN ULTNCY ADAMS.
Executive Department, Ca.,
Mdledgevillt, 27tb Jan. td27.
Sin—As the (Jthceis of Ueorgin engaged in
the execuuou of their duties near to its Western
bound.irv, liy order ot the Legislative and Exe
cutive authority of the State, have sutlere>l fie-
qorii iuteri upliuii from the 1 iidiaus ol I tie Cl ecu
iSiitioi accompanied hy indignities and insults
(uliiciently aggravated. and are still threatened
wnn oiac'K of more violent and outrageous
character; and, as there is reason to believe
tint lour Agent ol Indian Affairs is the prime
mover and instigator of the same, i have deem
ed it proper to lay before you the enclosed pa
pers in support of that belief, and to ask the fn-
r.r of you to inform me if that olliccr is so art-
jug by your authority, or with your sanction and
Countenance. It may be ihoiight painful e-
iiuugli that the United States, whose undoubted
It pit it is, shall eiitct into Conirovtis, \. ill) Geor
gia ou the vaud.ty of Treaties, and the lawful-
n, >sof boundaries, trespasses committed on the
one side, or right of sovereignty violated on the
Ola r, with the remedial or redressive measures
demanded ny citWi".
It is not to be presumed that the President
trould transfer the sovereign attributes to a su
baltern Vgeut, much less that he would delegate
tin m for the annoyance of the People of Geor
gia, far insult to their puboc functionaries, tor
invasion of (heir territorial rights, and finally
for bloodshed.
If these pow ers have been insolently assumed
bv such subaltern, for such purposes, it is not
fur the Governor of Georgia to dictate to the
President the measures which ought to billow,
as well in vindication of the honor of the United
tiiaies, as in reparation of the wrongs done to
Gioigia. the President is competent to judge
tin m, and the Governor doubts not his willing-
Bvismjudge them rightly.
With great consideration and respect,
G. M. TROUP.
The President of the tJ. States.
(.Here follow letters from Wiley Williams and
J 1 u.'S A. Rogers, District Surveyors, informing
•J" Troup of the interruption of t tie i r surveys
by the Indians, and enclosing a paper w ritten b
Crowell and signed by Little I'imm ...a .,tb.„*
Chiefs, forbidding the survey ]
The message niul papers were rent!, and
referred to the Select Committee to which
was referred ilte message of the 5th in=t.
HOUSE OF REPRESENTATIVES.
Thursday, Feb. 8.
' GREEK INDIANS.
Mr. Forsyth asked leave to lay on the
bnlile the following resolution :
MIlMNT RESOLUTION' to indemnify the Creek
1 Illinois fui'Jl” land Hiuq between the Cha-
Jmioiichinaiyer, and tne*dividing line between
MJeorgia and Aiabamief
'IhmU'td by Ike Senate and House of
Aalives of Ike’ United States of America in Ut> nmss
otsemvltdyiUM thejginT njiAf * dollars, 11 1>
Jy'id uut of any nioiu*vair'Alfb- Treasury, not o-
i "ise Rpjy oprintedf^Pi’iiinfer.the direction of
the President of the United States, distributed a-
* Wong the Creek Indians, as a full indemnity for
* their claim to hunt upoyL'Ar in any ufher man-
tleiu-e, the stiijhof land ly iu^JMI w een the tflia-
tahouchie river and the.dj'Tding line between the
State of Georgia mid /Alabama, which said land
is to he subject to the undistuructl occupiitiqn of
AH' citizens of Georgia, under the lawi*Df that
Stare,” C«l»
The Chair (Iccidefl^lhJt the resolution
^'nstitituotvin ordeef uiltoag Received' by
Uimnimnn* consent.^
Mr. Forsyth, rhofflpit that tlie 4M r^tvof
, f>rder allowed its,.presentation by special
( leave, _ ' <y ,.
■ The Speaker rcirttatf, that this was^not
f the rule yhicli regimes the monfin^^n
Biness of the. House; mid pronounced^ the
' Rtotioi, out of order.
i from this decis^eti Mr. Forsyth appeal
•cd; but niter some explanation it appear
'•'I that the Chair luwf iriiKUiiilerstood Mr
I orsyjli as moving the resolution, instead
ol which be had only asked leave to oiler it
1 his latter was declared to bo in order
a hd the question hemp put, leave was
Canted,and the resolution was received
end laid upon the ttfble until to-morrow.
Friday, February 9.
VMTED STATES AND GEORGIA.
A Message received yesterday front tin
President of the United Sintes, was laid
"' lore tiie House by the Speaker, and
Ip ad, [as inserted in the Journal of So
tiute Proceedings of yesterday.]
Mr. Forsyth moved to Iny tho Message
'Ton th e t u i,ie, but afterwards withdrew
•us motion ; when
Mr. Everett moved its reference to the
Uututnitiee on the Judiciary.
Mr. Forsyth moved that it be referred t,o
’ ''"miitteg qf th^> Whole to fhe.ntau; of
•uo Union.
Mr. lVicktiffe said, lie differed with
both the uemictnim from Massachusetts,
(Mr. Everett,) and the gentleman from
Georgia, (Mr. Forsyth.) as to the propriety
ol the course indicated by them. He was
against the reference of this subject to
either ofthe Committees proposed. And
before lie submitted the motion ho intend
ed to make, be would, under t>Lo indul
gence ol the House, assign briefly the t ea*
suns 'which iiillnutieed his judgment.
The question stiluniiti d liy tht! Presi
dent of the United States, in his Message,
was not one of mere ordinary legislation.
We were not called upon to remove, by
the action of this Hou-e, a temporary or
permanent evil which is found to exist in
the past legislation of the Congress ofthe
li. States. If so, be would not ca»o to
, wli.'it Committee it was referred, or how
soon this House acted upon '.ho subject.
But, sir, the question involves tho rights
ot a member of this Union, on t.,e one
side, and the powers ofthe United Unites
tint other. And this question grows
out of the supposed existence and validity
ol two treaties, heretofore made, under all
the sanctions ofthe constituted authori
ties ol tho United States, which treaties
are at variance with each other. Hy the
compact made \\ itb Georgia by the United
States, many years ago, the United States
tire bound to extinguish the Indian title to
all the. lands within the State of Georgia.
In iulfiltneiit ofthis obligation on the purl
ot the United States, Commissioners were
appointed by tho President to negotiate a
treaty with the Creek Indians. A treaty
was entered into between the U. State’s
and the Creek Indians, in February, 1823,
at the Indian Springs, by which, among
other things, the Indian title to all the
laud within the State of Georgia, was re
leased to that State ; this treaty was rati
fied by the Senate of tho United States,
file Creek Nati m of Indians, or, 1 should
sav, a portion at'the fioudmen and Chiefs
ol that Nation, objected to this Treaty, as
not having been made and agreed to by a
majority of the Warriors and Chiefs ol'
the tribe. I need not detain the House by
a detail of tlie consequences winch ensu
ed. They are familiar lo the House, and
to the Nation. To quiet this dilliculty
as no all believed and hoped—last Win
ter, during the session of Congress, anoth
er Trentv was entered into between the
(.'reek Nation anti the United States, by
which it is declared, that the Treaty of
the Indian Springs shall be annulled ami
set aside; and a new stipulation as lo the
boundary of cession and guarantee, was
defined. A part of the land which was
ceded to Georgia by the first Treaty, is,
by the provisions t i'tlie second, reserved
lo the Indians. Georgia contends that,
by the Treaty of the Indian Springs, nil
tlie lands w ithin her limits bccani" vested
in the Slate ; and that the second Treaty,
so far as it pretends to divest that right,
and guarantee it to the Indians, is void us
to her. This, I believe, is tlie true stale
of tlie question. Georgia lias directed the
nrveying of the land. The President
ontends that the act of the Legislature
Georgia is a violation ofthe Constituti-
, and the supreme law ofthe land; and
that the entry ofthe Purveyors of Georgia
ipon the Indian reservation is a violation
if the act of Congress ; and Jie lias conse-
icutly ordered the arrest and trial ofthe
Surveyors. Against thiscourse 1 hope—I
anuot believe otherwise—Georgia will through him, to the State which he hud tin
not protcsil >lt is a Judicial question ; it honor to represent, that, if that State pre-
has been referred by the President to that
tribunal; anti why should we be called
upon to mingle iti the excitement and feel
ings to winch this dedicate subject must
order, according to Parliamentary usage
in debate, in this branch of tlie Legislature,
to allude to proceedings of the other
inch—which, by tlie by, 1 have ulwuys
.night rather 'an inconvenient, jnle. If
fhe'*rulo were, that, when a sulijpA't was
pending in mio branch, it should not bo
*u;l4U oil in tlie other, fiiucli time, labor,
ticT'expense, would be saved. 15tft to
ty^f: Lai 11 be excused, on tho present
occasion, it^T make a reference to that
Avbi(ilt>iO have aJl seen and beard, ami
winch is now undeV the action of the
^Senate. This subject has, ulsOj Irften
submitted by the President to that bo
dy. They have appointed their Cotn-
cnmmtinication to the Committee on the
Judiciary, lie thought the appropriate
reference would be a Select Committee.
Indeed, be thought it was not proper to
refer it to any one of the standing Com
mittees of the House. The duty ofthe
Judi‘iury Committee was to take cogui
.’.mice of those questions which belonged
to tlie Judicial Department of the Govern
ment ; but this subject was of a character
which carried on its front the most alarm
ing aspect. It was a subject of vital im
port,nice, and one which pre-eminently
called for full deliberation.
Ho understood that, on n lata occasion,
in this House, some gentlemen bad allud
ed to certain acts of sovereignty, ednteni-
plitietl by independent Statesol' tbis Union
—that those States had been denounced,
ami bad been expressly told that they
i would proceed at their peril. Tlios'c
Slides, Mr. O. said, were fully aware of
tbenttiiinle in which they stood,&ocertain
ly should not l./oK to tins House to receive
tie: denunciations of individuals represent
ing a diilafctitdistrict ofthe Union. They
contemplated doing only what they had a
right to do, anil every State would be
treacherous to itself .should it refuse to
extend its legislation over the whole of its
chartered limits, and all persons therein
contained. The sovereign Slates of this
Confederacy most unquestionably bad
power to decide on tho character of any
ucts of the Government; and, if those
acts were unconstitutional, they bad u
right so to declare, A to refuse their sub
mission. \\ hutever consetjuences might
ensue, from the existing state of things,
with respect to Georgia, the responsibility
would not bo <m his head ; for he hud
warned the House to pause before it act
ed its it hud done at tho last Session. He
did not, however, wish to be understood
as saying that any State would attempt to
resist the judgment expressed by the whole
Confederacy. He presumed there was
not a State in the Union which would
think of tlii*1: every State would acquiesce
in the opinion ofthe Union : all they wish
ed for was, an expression of that opinion.
When this was given, Georgia, lie was
sure, would immediately acquiesce, ami
so would the State lie had the honor to
represent. It was far from being desira
ble to either to come in collision with the
General Government; but they were as
fully acquainted with the extent of their
rights as any one of the Representatives
on tbi s floor. He thought, upon the \v hole,
that his friend from Georgia would do
better to triox -• a reference ofthe commu
nication to a Select Committee. This
was a question which ought to be deli
berately investigated, and decided without
passion or excitement. It was a very im-
portant cjuooinjn, ai**l one which, ir
to uKtronrity, might issue in the overthrow-
ofthe liberties ol'tbis Republic.
Mr. Unite said, that lie had risen for tlie
purpose of propounding a few interroga
tories to a gentleman from Massachusetts,
(Mr. Ir’ebstcv,)' who had addressed the
House a few days since. He was at that
time precluded from any reply to the
gentleman's remarks, and had lie not been
so precluded, lie might at this time hu\u
bail cause for sincere regret for what he
might then have said. Being, as he was,
the sole Representative of a sovereign
State, it had been with pain that he had
heard a threat proclaimed to him, and
sortie Committee—either„that ou tlie Judi
ciary or it Select Committee, as it should
determine. It was very possible that
some new act of Legislation might ho ne
cessary ; and, independently of the vari
ous important inquiries which might be
gone into, tins Commit we would have to
look into the sever!*! lows of tlie State of
Georgia, which had any bearing on the
general subject. A collation and presen
tation of these laws was an important
tusk of such a committee,and was mani
festly unsuitable to a Committee of the
Whole House, lie purpomly abstained
from touching, at tins time, the general
merits of this controversy, as all sttcli dis-
etission was, ia Ins judgment, «t this tiuie
p etiiattire.
Mr. iiauhnnan aid, heregretted that the
gentleman from Kentucky, (Mr. tUieletilfe)
Irttd withdrawn his motion to lay the mes
sage ofthe President upon the table. He
believed intH-h greater importance had
been attached to the subject, than fairly
belonged in if. fn his opinion,it involved
no question of a civil war—nothing widen
ought to alarm the imagination of the
mo>;t lin.jd. 1 It! thought tiie subject should
be laid upon ilia table, or referred to n
Committee ofthe Whole on the stale of
the Union, where he hoped it might sleep.
Georgia claims all tho laud within het
boundaries, under what has been culled
the Treaty ofthe Indian Springs. The
present. Administration of the General
Goveriuncyl allege, that the rights of!
Georgia have hee.il limited by the subse-|
pleat treaty of Washington. ’ That State
sorry it has lieen referred to any Commit-
lee in anoritr body. It should have been
I'd! exclusively to the Courts of Justice.
For the purpose of preventing the ungry
discussion which would probably arise
upon Ibis subject, Mr. B. said lie would
move to lay tlie message on the table.
Mr. h'e.bsftr observed, that the question
before the House was a mere question res
pecting Committees to which this coniuin-
mention was to lie referred. Ho should
confute his remarks to this question, anil
could not, therefore, without violating the
proper order of debate, make any reply to
the remarks which bad fallen from the
gentleman from Pennsylvania, on the-ge-
iieiul topics eotiuiinod in the o.oirumnyca-
uon from the Executive. He thought tiie
eommuiiiciitiiMi ought logo to some com
mittee which might be competent to os-
eynuin w l;eilior the whole matter was be
fore the House, mid whether uny iegisln
•hui would lie nectvsury. lie was not at
all solicitous to send it to any particular
committee ; and certainly not to that com
mittee with which he was Himself con
nected. As one of that committee, he
would say that they would not seek tlie
reference imr shun it if it were made. But
undoubtedly it ought to go to some com
mittee, thoi e especially as there was a pro
position upon the table which looked to le-
gislntion on tlie subject. This was the
ordinary and usual course in relation to
Executive communications, and, Mr. W.
said, he saw no reason why this should
not follow tho usual routine.
Mr. W. agreed with tlie gentleman from
possesses the unquestionable right ofl.av- j Alabama, that the subject was both impor
,1 ’ , “ “ ' ' (mit mid delicate. But he did not think
that it was so very ulurming a matter as
that gentleman seemed to suppose.—
I here were tit least two sides to the ques
tion ; and If there was danger in deny
ing the authority of any uct of a Brute, sq,
on the oilier hand, it must bo allowed
there was danger in denying the validity
of a treaty made under ihe authority of
the U. Slates, and duly ratified. Tlie
ing this question determined la fore tlie
Judicial Tribunals ofthe Country. She
has sent her surveyois into tlie Territory
in dispute, for tlie purpose of surveying
tht! land ; and it does not at present occur
to me, in what otiier manner the question
could have been raised fur Judicial deter
mination. In this state of the controver
sy, the President ofthe U. States has cer
tainly pursued the proper course—the
nurse which the Constitution and lawsui t whole subject was one well worthy ol
e rise, il’diseiissed in this House, now that gentleir
at any other tittrer* .. 1id
sumed to legislate on a particular subject,
over which he believed it had entire con
trol, it would do so on its own responsi
bility, and at its peril. lie wished to ask
mail whether such a threat
. .- . , itmlu eruudiu. well to all other
i have another reasdn, still mere satis- | aetsol sovereign legislation by tntum
ctory to my mind, why we should not | other Stale? lie wished to ask him
now consider this subject, in or out oft whether this language was to awe any
Jouimittee. I know it is not strictly in State of this Confederacy, however small,
and if, when thus threatened, she mu.-t
submit as a matter of'eouise? If this
was so, then lie would say, with the Poet,
‘‘ Farewell—u long farewell to all my”
country’s “greatness.” He was fully
aware that, whenever n State discharged
any duty which fell within its Constituti
onal power, it did so on its own responsi
bility. But lie greatly regretted that vvliat
was a wanting m form, but a threatening
infant, should have been issued liy any
geiitluinan on this floor. Whcncq was
this gentleman’s authority for any such
threat derived ? Was it from his power
or influence in this House, or had he lit
tcreti it ns the organ of tiie Atlmitiistraii-
nnttce, and referred the'subject to their I on, who are to bo understood as proclaim
immeihm^ attention, where, I have no ing that they would use the military forct
will be well considered, and of the country against any State which
whine it ought to he considered. The should tlms presume ? In the remarks
lifliculty has arisen under a treaty—the which be hud tumle, Mr. II. said, be bail
President ami the Senate afe the trei^y-| been governed hy no spirit of faction. He
making power. It is u question invtdv- | had no wish to produce excitement, and
as 1 before said, on the one side, the j would be the last to light up the lurch of
sovereignty of a State ; on the other,/!he | civil war. But the legislature of Mi.-sis-
his country clearly prescribed. He lot
directed the Dnrvoyors of Georgia to he
arrested, and to be brought before a Judi
cial Tribunal for trial. Upon this trial, the
respective claims ofthe United States and
of Georgia will be fully and fairly iuvesti
gated, and their l ights will he detet mined.
This and this only is the question ; and
the whole question.
Is there a tittle of testimony before this
House tending to prove that Georgia
will not submit peaceably to tho judg
ment of the Court, whatever it may be <—
It would he doing injustice to that Stale,
for a moment to suppose, that she would
not yield obedience to the lawn of the
j a g[ { then, what necessity is
tfiere tur legtslautui j
Can legislation, at preseut, fairly influ
ence the rights of tin* parties ? The issue
is joined between them, and must be de
cided according to existing laws. Sir,
said Mr. B. although I believe the Presi
dent has acted with the strictest proprie
ty, in referring this question to the Judici
ary, yet I must be permitted to say, that,
in another particular, I cannot yield him
my approbation, lie ought not to have
prejudged the ease, nut) proclaimed bis o-
piniou to this House, untl to*tlie country.
The law should have been permitted to
take its regular course. The opinion of
the President ought not to have been east
into tlie scale, cither on one side, or the o-
ther. That opinion has bepn decidedly
given against the State of Georgia. 1 do
not profess to be a warm admirer of the
President, but yet I feel great respect for
any opinion be lias deliberately formed.—
It is entitled to much consideration, and
•iit would have been the more
proper i-» qonceuled it whilst the
cause was depending. Here tu.. ». . ^«a
the following extract from the message of
the President :
“ It ought not, however, to be disguised, that
“the act of the Legislature of Georgia, under t >e
“ construction given to it by the Governor of that
“.State, and thu surveys made, or attempted, by
“Ids authority, beyond Ihe boundary secured by
“ the Treaty of Washington, of April lest, to tlie
“Creek Indians, are in direct violation of the Su-
“premo Law of this land, set forth inaTreaty,
“ which has received all the sanctions provided by
“tlie Constitution, which we have been sworn lo
"support and maintain.”
Thus the Executive has assumed that
the State of Georgia is wrung, which is
the very question to |ie decided. Ho lias
determined that Georgia lias violated tlie
Constitution and the laws; although this
! is the very matter which he bus submitted
ing that they w ould use the military force j to tho Judiciary for their decision, lie
hits prejudged the ruse. The President,
in another part of his message, lias held
out it threat against Georgia—although
the question whether he has acted illegal-
power of this Government." In the Se
nate, the sovereignties of tho States are
exclusively represented. To my mind,
the question is one which peculiarly be
longs to the consideration of that body.—
At all events, 1 am anxious to wait their
action ; and if limy shall decide that le
gislation is necessary, I will co-operate
with gentlemen, by my best etlbrts to do
and perform vvliat it is lit vve shall do, 1
tint extremely anxious, at this late period
of the session, to avoid the discussion ;
angry, as 1 fear it will be, if'tbis delicate
question, is to be considered ; when 1 ^Standing Committees of the House, and
have the strongest conviction it maybe by no means to a Committee ot the \\ bole
settled, if not by the Senate immediately, oil the state of tlie Union. To tfie proper
certainly by the Judiciary. But let it lie and enlightened discussion of such u suh-
sippi did contend for its authority to ex
tend its jiower ttf legislation throughout
the whole of its chartered limits, as well
over the Italians us over the white popu
lation. Ifshe was restrained from doing
this, site ceased to bo it 8tate.
Mr. Powell agreed with gentlemen, that
this was a highly important subject. But
reflection bail confirmed him in theoj mi-
on, which he had expressed when anoilmf
communication bad been received in rela
tion to it, that Bought logo cither to a Se
lect Committee, or to some one of the
settled in any way, save by the nppieation
of military force against a member of this
Union. Under tins view of the subject,
and with a hope tiie House will acquiesce
in the course, 1 move you the subject lie
upon the table.
Mr. VV. withdrew his motion, however,
at tht! instance of Mr. Oita.*;, but, ns lie
said with a determination to renew it.
Mr. Owen suid that he had not risen to
enter into any* discussion ot the general
question, but to say, that lie could not per-
Cciv© any regton f-" - tho rctcreuce of tins
ject, it wag necesgary, as a preliminary
step, that many unit various facts should
he correctly ascertained. It was obvious-
Iv impossible that this could be done in a
Committee of the Whole House. It re
quired a committee of another kind. Tlie
question to be settled iv.ns a question on
tht! construction of laws mid the interpre
tation of treaties.
This was a subject for calm and close
investigation, and the House was entitled
have the result of such an examination
ly is still [tending and undetermined.—
Hero Mr. Uwhanan read the following
extract from the message:
“ lit the present instance, it is my duly to say,
“that, if the Legislative atp! Executive Vtitliori
■ ties of the State of Georgia should pcrsevetc in
"acts of eiieii.u Imicnt upon the territories secur-
“e«l by a solemn Treaty totin' Indians, and the
"law s of the Union remain unaltered, it sapei atl-
" ded obligation, even higher than that of human
“authority, will compel the Kxoeutive of the U.
“States to enforce the laws, X: fulfil the duties of
“the Nation, by nil the force committed for that
“purpose to his charge.”
It may he the duty of the Executive tints
to act, iii chsu the State of Georgia should
persevere, after the determination of her
ights lias been referred to the Judiciary.
nature deliberation. One word,said M..
v\ as to tlie honorable member from Mis
sissippi: When any member ofthe House
asks of me an explanation of any thing
f.etsonal as to himself, 1 am ready to make
n : il any gentleman qsks an explanation
as to any facts, or utiy argument, or a
clearer statement of any argument I have
.Advanced, I um ready, ut all times, to
comply with his wishes. For all other
purposes, I cannot submit to be catechis
ed; and to some ofthe queries which that
gentleman proposed to me, I shuil, there
fore, give no answer.
Mr. W. went on to say, that lie had me
naced nobody ; lie bad uttered no threats,
ns seemed to be supposed; but, ou tiie
him to come from the other side, and not
from bis side of tlie question ; of that,
however, the House would judge. What
was this whole matter ? Was il offensive
to sovereign States for him to say that
they acted, in any particular matter, ou
their own responsibility, and at their pe
ril? Sir, those States do HCt at tlieir pe
ril; and if they undertake to extend tlieir
legislation in the manner referred to, they
»h. so on their responsibility, and at tlieir
peril, i shall not take back a syllable of
what I said, either in manner or sub
stance. I wish to be understood as re
peating it, word for word, and syllable for
syllable. Sir, what are the circumstan
ces oftlie case? The lands over which
these Status claim to exorcise exclusive
jurisdiction, have never lieen subject to
Slate laws from the foundation of this Go
vernment ; the control of those lands has
always beet) with the Congress of the U.
States. Wc regulate the sale of those
lands, or rather we forbid the purcltaao of
tiiKtit t'j- tnjti/iJifiils, We enact all. gape
nil regulations rnn.ioitiftig tho Indian
Tribes who inhabit them. Their munici
pal concerns have hitherto been managed
by themselves: they maintain their own
peace und their own laws. It was now
said, that the State of Alabama and Mis
sissippi either hud extended, or intended
shortly to extend, their legislation to the
lands and persons of these Indians. They
will therein do, vvliat ha# never been dpno
or attempted before, and vvliat has at least
a very doubtful aspect; and, when I said
that they must do this on their responsibi
lity arid at tlieir peril, I meant no more
than that they would venture on the exer
cise of a power which they might be found
not to possess. Does tiie gentleman ciqI
thi;< language minatory, and come here a
week afterwards, with a list of guest ions
which bo wishes to propound to me as to
w hat 1 meant by the observations I made?
I tell that geiitietnan that 1 mean vvliat i
say. 1 api to hi tit At tiie proposed measure
will be tho act of u Sovereign State. Be
it so. Is it not a possible thing that a So
vereign .State may sometimes act in a man
ner which violates the Constitution ? Are
not conflicting laws of a State and of the
United Stales to be discussed and settled
for or against a State, before the Judicial
Tribunal ? If l and my learned friends
were jn another part of this Capitol, vve
can speak of these things without offence,
and the judgment comes upon them, with
out offence. There, ot least, it is admit
ted to ho very possible, that a Sovereign
State may be in the wrong.
befuro it, in the shape of a report from of this controversy to the Judiciary. 1 um
It is not my intention now to discuss the
} general question, or to go into all extend
ed reply to the observations which hnve
Upon this point*I shall not at present ex- been made upon it ; but I um told by the
press any opinion. But, sir, was such honorable gentleman from Georgia (Mr.
language of the 1‘resjdeut conciliatory to- FnkSY*ru) that tho Courts are open, and
wards it sister State? Or was it not ra- that this question may be settled by a Ju-
tliter calculated to prov oke that State, and dicial Tribunal. This might have been
produce the very evil which lie dreads?—I a return kaldy £ood argument to address
l hope. Georgia mny submit peaceably to | to the State ol Georgia before she,took
the Judicial tribunals of her country. If j tlie remedy into her own hands. It is a
she should not, she will not receive my new mode of settlinga Constitutional qttoB-
support. 1 (rust, also, site w ill forbear j tioti, to seize the lands in dispute, and
from the expression of those angry feci-j scud out the Hancock troop of hoi'sc to
' defend the possession of them. But, itt
this stage ofthe all'uir, that appeal to the
Courts comes with rather alt awkward
grace. When a limn advuncos a claim a
gains' the lands of bis ueigli|jor, be inak.es
mgs, which the occasion is well calculat
ed to excite.
I repi at, the President l as my entire ap
probation so far ns rc/iiccts the reference
No. 4, or VuL. ViII.
bis appeal to the law ; but, when he for
cibly enters upon possession of thorn, bo
makes his appeal to something different
from the law.
[Hero Mr. Hamilton called the gentle*
man to order, uml, when called upon by
the Chair to point out wherein Mr. H’eh-
s/rr was out of order, lie explained him
self us wishing to prevent any course of
remark which might tend to produce ex*
citcment. Tho CJinlr decided that Mr.
fVehster was in order.]
Mr. W. resumed : I have no intention
to produce excitement ou this subject, but
I have my own opiuions upon it. 1 be
lieve them to be tenable, and, at a proper
lime, I shall not forbear to express then*
in this House, l-bave been induced, oa
the present occasion, to make some re
marks which 1 should tiot have made, had
not the inquiries of the gentleman from
Mississippi called me out. Mr. VV. con
cluded liy expressing bis hope, that tlia
matter would ho allowed to take the usu
al course of reference to a Committee lor
examination.
Mr. Everett observed, that, as lie had
the honor to submit one of the motions
now before tlie House, bo felt it bis duty
to explain the reasons why he had douq
so. In the first pluce, in reply to the gen
tleman from Kentucky, (Mr. Wicemite,)
who thought vve ought not to act ut all on
the subject while it was before the other
brunch ofthe Legislature, he would say,
that there vvbh one view of it, in which it
not only becomes proper that the House
also should act, bn. absolutely necessury.
There is now on our tables, said Mr. E. a
joint resolution, moved yesterday by the
member from Georgia, which goes direct,
ly to tlie subject-matter of the coutrover*
sy, which requires an act of legislation;
ail appro) Uatnm of money to extinguish
the Indian title to the land in dispute ; mid
ibis uct ol legislation must originate hero.
Sir, 1 hope tin* resolution will be adopted.
The gentleman from Georgia shall hava
my leeble aid in obtaining the appropria
tion. I am willing to give five times—ten
times, the value of the land, (which, in.
tuct, is said to be of no great worth,) t®
come to a peaceable adjustment of so un*
pleasant a controversy. It is, then, a pro
per subject ofthe legislative action ot" this
House.
As regards the particular reference, said
Mr. E ., I can, of course, have no strong
feeling, nor any reason pnculiur to myself,
for preferring one committee over another.
There are some facts apparently in con*
troversy—some principles ou which dirt’e*
rent judgments exist. Are not these pro
per subjects of investigation, before tho
House can act on the matter ? The Ju
diciary Committee appeared to him tho
nroner CoimnijUiH : liar, tlieguliiiuui wen.
construction of treaties of this Govern
ment, and the force and application of the
laws oftlie United States und the State of
Georgia. I ask, then, (said Mr. E.)ou tho
first blush oftlie matter, whether the Ju
diciary Committee does not immediately
suggest itself usibe appropriate commit
tee for the inquiry ? True, it is an im
portant inquiry; fur more so than many
ofthe matters sent to thut Committee, or
the other Committees of the House.——
What then ? Because business is Impor
tant, w ill j on tukc it out of tlie due course
of proceeding ? Because it is important,
will you object to sending it to the very
Committee within whose jurisdiction it
falls? Its importance is tlie very reu-on
why I would refer it to its appropriate
Committee. An interpretation of laws, a
construction of treaties, and an investiga
tion of facts connected with them, aio
wanted in a very important cuse. For
that reason, I would resort to that one of
the Committees of the House, whose pe
culiar duty it is to entertain such questions.
Sir, it is xn important, but not, I trust,
an alarming subject; quite important e-
nougli to receive the prompt' attention of
the House, but not of a nature to excite
apprehensions os to the result. Recent
intimations hnve been received, (it is said)
which bold out a hope of amicable adjust-
moot.
Mr. Hamilton said, that he regretted that
the gentleman from Kentucky, (Mr. Hick-
liffe) had withdrawn bis motion, that the
subject under consideration should, for the
present, lie ou the table, lie moreover
regretted that tlie President shqtild have-
felt it necessary to send this matter to riio
House, when, on tiie face of his own mes
sage, it did not appear that be bail asked
the legislative action of Congress, or ihitl.
he hud submitted uny specific propositions
to us.
The true statu of tho case is briefly this ;
certain difficulties, growing out ofthe con
struction of a treaty or treaties, which,
form the Supreme law of the land, have
ensued between Georgia and the Genera]
Government; these difficulties have ar
rived at sttcli a state that they are about to
take that course which every one must
tpost desire who values the peace of the
country, to wit : to be placed In a train of
judicial investigation and decision, by
which, whilst an important constitutional
question will be scaled, justice may hedmiQ
to the parties, and the ‘tranquility of th»
country preserved. |n ibis state of the
dispute, have we any thing to do with it ?
Does the President call upon us to supply
any new power to Jho Executive urm ?—
Hits lie called upon us to pass uuj luvy to
nid the judicial authority ofthe counjry ?
lias lie told us that war is lo be made up
on Georgia, and, therefore, the military
resources oftlie country are to be organiz
ed ami placed ot bis disposal ? No, sir :
lie lias barely informed us, that he has di
rected the Surveyors acting under tlie au
thority of the State of. Gcorgiu, to be ar
rested for trial, and has intimated that, if
she resist tlie judicial power of Ihe United
States, be may bate occasion to make an
other anil a different appeal.
Has Georgia resisted ? Has this crisis
arisen ? And why, then, entertain a c* E
enssiou at this period, which can only
bate the pernicious tenilenct of provok
ing excite men i, tfonsumiug tijuae, and cuff