Newspaper Page Text
TTTF! ATT ANT A OFOR GIAN AlxT) NEWS.
'WE ONLY DID OUR DUTY; SAYS MAN WHO HELPED CONVICT FRANK
Dorsey’s Plea of Great Weight—Only Wondered at Prisoner’s Statement
AND VERDICT REACHED
The Georgian to-day reveals some of the innermost secrets of
the Jury which convicted Leo M. Frank of the murder of little
Mary Phagan. This inside story of the greatest criminal case in
the South’s history is an intensely interesting revelation of the
workings of men’s minds. It covers three long weeks and more
throughout which the evidence for and against the pencil factory
superintendent was tediously unfolded, link by link.
It casts upon the various points made by the defense and the
prosecution the light in which they were viewed by the twelve men
who were chosen to act as the judges. It ends with the last memor
able meeting of these men on the top floor of the courthouse Mon
day afternoon which culminated in the fateful verdict: “We thej
jury find the defendant guilty.”
The information is given here
with as it was obtained by a re
porter for this newspaper from
one of the jurors late Monday
night while the full weight of
his grim burden still rested upon
him. It is told in his own, im
pressive words.
"It was th« only thin* we could do.
The evidence was against Frank from
start to finish. And so we did our
duty, as we had sworn to do.
Dorsey’s Youth and
Sincerity Won.
"It would be hard to say what, of
all the trial, made the greatest im
pression on the jury. It was prob
ably the Solicitor General himself.
He was a marvel. His youthful ap
pearance, coupled with his sincerity,
made a wonderful hit. There wasn’t
a minute of the hours that he spoke
that he didn’t seem to mean every
word that he uttered.
“Dorsey is a forceful speaker. He
puts emphasis behind his words. And
he drives his points clear in and
clinches them on the other side. They
stuck with us. They had the evi
dence behind them to make them
stick.
“His theory of the murder was the
cne we accepted It was the one the
evidence upheld. That was the way
Frank killed that girl.
“While the negro watched down
stairs, he took the little girl back into
the metal room and struck her, and
then with a cord strangled her to
death. Then those notes were writ
ten as the negro told us and placed
beside the body.
in Dorsey’s argument there was
one little sentence which seemed to
Imbed itself in the minds of every
man on the jury, whr 1 he was speak
ing of the ag^p ement between Frank
and Conley that the negro should
come back to the factory and burn
the body. The sentence was this:
‘And if the smoke from that little
girl’s burning body had gone curling
up into the air, old Jim Conley would
have hanged for another man’s crime.'
Hooper’s Action
Had Its Effect.
“Those words went a long way to
ward keeping Jim Conley from hang
ing. probably. They drew a contrast
between right and wrong which made
us look again into the evidence before
us. And the narrow escape which the
negro had made us shudder.
“There was another thing which
Impressed that jury. It was Frank
Hooper’s sacrifice ot Dorsey. We call
ed it that. Hooper had the chance of
his lifetime there to make a wonder
ful speech when he opened the State’s
argument. We were half expecting
one. His reputation was known to
us. And when he ended there was
some disappointment. We said he had
not done his best.
“Then we saw his sacrifice. He had
only made a plain statement of the
State's case and left for tbu Solicitor
General whatever fame and fortune
there was to be won by the State’s
counsel.
“The jury heard none of the cheer
ing for Dorsey outside the courtroom
at any time. We heard the crowds in
the courtroom laugh ac times, and we
laughed, too, but that had no effect.
“Probably the hardest job we had
was to sit there and face Frank’s mo
ther and his wife with the slowiy
growing feeling of the defendant’s
guilt. Some of the jurors cried when
Frank’s wife broke down following
his speech. It was an impressive
thing to ue. Yet i' didn’t affect the
evidence.
Frank’s Speech
Caused Wonder,
‘The trouble with Frank’s speech
was the same as the trouble with the
entire defense. The evidence declared
to us that he was guilty and no words
of his could disprove that fact. Every
body felt the weight his wonderful
calm and dispassionate manner car
ried while he was talking. Yet the
marvel was that a guilty man could
do it. That was all.
“The defense made a wonderful
fight with the evidence they had. Mr.
Arnold was admired for his skillful
work by every member of the jury
We saw every point that he brought
out, and yet they all lacked weight.
“Probably nothing else in the whole
case was of more interest to us than
Luther Rosser’s crosa-examination of
Conley. We thought It was a mas
ter’s display of human Ingenuity. Yet
In the jury’s mind It was like a sky
rocket, soaring up into the heavens
to cast Its fountain of brilliance about
and then die out. The negro’s story
remained as he had told it. That had
a tremendous effect in the verdict.
“Then there was that cabbage. It
was astonishing the amount of knowl
edge displayed by the members
of the jury when the technicalities of
medicine were brought out. We un
derstood It all. The specimen of cab
bage taken from the little Phagan
girl’s stomach was passed around
amongst us In the jury room and we
could easily see that it had not been
digested.
“That also had Its effect. There
were men amongst us who luckily
were well up on digestion. The ex
perts said very little that we did not
understand. But I will venture to say
that few of the men of that jury will
ever eat cabbage again.
Full Force of
Duty Strikes Home.
“It is a terrific thing to be on a
Jury which holds a man’s life in its
hands. The weight seems heaviest
during the early days of the trial.
Tou are struck with the somber faces
of your fellow Jurymen first; then in
the mirror you see that your own
face Is as somber as the rest, and
the full force of the duty in front of
you strikes home. Tou realize that
before you become a free man again
you shall have disposed of the life of
a fellow man.
“Yet, strange to say, there wasn’t
one among us who tried to flinch from
his full share of the work. Each
seemed eager from the start to do
what he had sworn to do, and the de
termination seemed to grow as the
days passed. When we left the court
room this afternoon with the Judge’s
charge there wasn’t a doubt In the
mind of anyone of us that Justice
would be done. I think that thought,
in a great measure, was the cause
for our quick decision.
"Of course, we didn't dream that
the case would last as long as It did.
Some of us hadn’t prepared for It. It
meant a loss of a great deal of money I
to many of the men. Tet when this ;
was brought up along in the second I
week, when no end was in sight, it
took only one mention of the task be
fore us to make all else look Infin
itesimally small. Jurydom is a sphere
where money is not known.
First Week Was
Longest of All.
"The first week of the trial was
longer than all the rest put togeth
er. It was a bit difficult for us to get
acquainted. We were all a little bit
suspicious of each other. Outside of
a few comments on immaterialities,
practically nothing was said about
the case. We didn’t care to t alk
about It, even to our roommates.
“Then somebody brought in a
checker board and someone else a
deck of cards. The social life in jury
quarters blossomed out in full blast.
“It was a most welcome diversion,
too. We had little enough exercise
a*s it was and there was nothing left
but to brood on the case.
“And by the middle of the second
week- there wasn’t a more sociable
and jolly set of men this side of
heaven. I don’t believe. There were
checker matches and setback tourna
ments and a great rivalry for the
championships. I don’t believe that
there was an amateur among the
bunch which went into that jury who
didn’t come out an expert. With
nothing else to do much at night one
can learn a great deal about cards
and checkers in three weeks.
“There was no gambling. And each
Sunday we read from the Bible and
sang religious songs. In fact, we held
regular services every Sabbath day.
It didn’t matter what churches we
belonged to, each was as fervent as
the other. ' While in Rome we did
Trial a Farce, Say Attorneys
L. Z. Rosser and Reuben Arnold, counsel for Leo Frank, issued the following statement this
jnorning:
“We deem it nbt amiss to make a short statement, as the attorneys of Leo M. Frank, to the
public.
“The trial which has just occurred, and which has resulted in Mr. Frank’s conviction, was
a farce and not in any way a trial. In saying this, we do not make the least criticism of Judge
Roan who presided. Judge Roan is one of the best men in Georgia, and is an able and conscien
tious judge.
“The temper of the public mind was such that it invaded the courtroom ad pervaded the
streets and made itself manifest at every turn the jury made; and it was just as impossible for
this jury to escape the effects of this public feeling as if they had been turned loose and had
been permitted to mingle with the people.
“In doing this we are making no criticism of the jury. They were only men, and uncon
sciously this prejudice rendered any other verdict impossible.
“It would have required a jury of stoics, a jury of Spartans, to have withstood this situa
tion.
“The time ought to come when this man wall get a fair trial, and we profoundly believe
that it will.
“The final judgment of the American people is a fair one. It is sometitnes delayed in com
ing, hut it comes.
“We entered into this case with the profound conviction of Mr. Frank’s innocence. The re
sult has not changed our opinion. Every step of the trial has intensified and fortified our pro
found conviction of his innocence.
“L. Z. ROSSER,
“R, R. ARNOLD.”
as the Romans do. Seriously, though,
I think that the proposition we were
up against in judging of a man’s life
had a good deal to do with that
fervor.
Same Word On
Each Jury Slip.
“As for the judgment we passed,
there is little to Bay. As weighty as
the task may seem, it was simple.
There was but one ballot and on the
twelve slips which were handed into
Foreman Winburn the single word
‘guilty’ was written. Yet, no one
seemed surprised. There was a
unanimity of feeling amongst us.
“Don’t think that we had not con
sidered the case fully. And don’t
think that there was a man amongst
us that wanted to do what we did.
Yet, day after day, the pressure grew
heavier, as the case was put before
us. From a slight dread it became
an oppression; then a nausea and at
last a sickening sense of the grim
fact—that Frank was guilty and we
were going to give the world that
verdict.
“It was horrible—that time we
spent in deliberation. Everyone
knew what was going to be done,
though hardly a word was spoken,
until we had agreed. We were
spellbound with dread. Then some
one suggested a drink. That en
livened us and we began to breathe
again.
“You ask what brought us to our
verdict so readily? I have told you.
It was the only thing that could be
done, and we knew It, even as we
ascended the stairs to the juryroom
this afternoon. No argument was
needed.”
Pierce Loses Pinkerton Job
By Actions in Phagan Case
Took Car for Try-out
And Did Not Return
CORDELE, Aug. 26.—The theft of
a big touring car in broad day
light is the latest sensation in Cor-
dele. The automobile belongs to Frank
Teuber. The stranger who attempted
to get away with it is not known here.
He told Mr. Teuber he was going to
start an automobile hack line, claim
ing to have had two machines al
ready. He took the car for a try-out.
which extended to Tifton, when the
machine got out of order and he put
it in a garage there. He has not been
heard of since.
Senator's Kin Killed
In Row Over Saddle
RENO, NEV., Aug. 26.—William
Billings, son-in-law of former Sena
tor Plum, of Kansas, was killed on
a ranch lOO'miles north of Elko. Nev.,
by Frank Huber. Huber was ar
rested.
Billings took a saddle from Huber’s
stable, saying it was as security for
a debt.
Are You Sick, Diseased,
Nervous, Bun Down?
Have You Blood Poison, Kidney,
Bladder and Urinary Troubles?
IF SO. CONSULT (FREE)
Dr Huflm. Atlanta's L#n. Eitabtlsti.d,
Moat Rallabl. Sboalallst.
I cure to *tay
cured
ICERTI, BLOOD
and ftMn Diseases.
STRICTURE,
Prostatic Trouble*.
VARICOCELE.
HYDROCELE.
Kidney, Bladder
and Urinary
Dlaeaae*. Piles and
All Chronic and
Private
Diseases of Men
' and Women.
I five 60«. the celebrated German pr*ff.ara-
tlon. for Blood Poiaon. and Guarantee re-
aults. Everythin* absolutely confidential.
If yeu can’t call, write.
Free Consultation and Advice to all.
HOURS— 0 a. m. to 7 p. m. Sundays. 9 to 1.
DR. HUGHES
Opposite Third National Bank.
16'.i N. Broad 8t.. Atlanta. GA.
Asa result of the charges ma^e by
the police of unfair dealings by the
Pinkerton operatives in the Investi
gation of the Phagan case, H. B.
Pierce, superintendent of the agency
in Atlanta, tendered his resignation.
It was promptly acceptr by A. L.
Corwardin, general superintendent, of
New Orleans, who arrived in the city
Monday.
Insubordination to the agency’s rule
demanding the co-operation of its op
eratives with the local police in crim
inal investigations was charged
against the superintendent.
The specific charge which brought
about the removal of Pierce grew out
of the finding of the blood-stained
stick on the first floor of the pencil
factory by Pinkerton operatives. It
was claimed by the police that the
stick was withheld from them by
Pierce, to whom 1: was turned in by
the finders, and the butt of a buggy
whip substituted. The stick itself was
turned over to the defense.
“This action by Mr. Pierce was In
direct opposition to the rules of the
Pinkerton Agency,” said Mr. Cor-
wardin. “Our charter to operate in
Atlanta carries the agreement that
our men withhold nothing from the
city police which they may secure in
investigations of criminal cases.
“Explicit orders demanding that this
agreement be carried through to the
letter have been in effect in the At
lanta office since the agency w'as
started here, and when Mr. Pierce
disobeyed them, there was but one
thing left to do.”
While no intimation was given by
General Superintendent Corwardin as
to who would be Pierce’s successor, 4t
is generally reported that Harry Scott
would be appointed to fill the posi
tion. The report Is founded on the
withdrawal of Scott’s appointment to
the superintendency of the Houston,
Texas, office, which was made shortly
before the charges against Pierce
were made publl- This promotion ->f
Scott was made as a result of his
work in the Phagan case investiga
tion, in which he was the field mar
shal for the Pinkertons.
Mr. Corwardin admitted that Scott
would stay in Atlanta.
CUNETTI SEES
JURY PISSED
TD Till Hill
SAN FRANCISCO, Aug. 26.—F.
Drew Caminettl, son of Anthony
Caminettl, Commissioner General of
Immigration, surrounded by four law
yers and comforted by his brother.
Anthony Caminettl, Jr., an attorney
of Sacramento, watched the prelimi
nary steps of his trial as a white
slaver before Federal Judge VanFleet
to-day.
His wife and mother did not appear
with Caminettl to-day. The elder
Mrs. Caminettl has been ill since the
conviction of Maury I. Diggs on the
same charge for the elopement to
Reno of Caminettl. Diggs, Marsha
Warrington and Lola Norris.
Diggs, who will be sentenced on
September 2. was not In court to-day
to watch the selection of a Jury from
the 50 men of the regular Jury panel.
It was expected by Special Prose
cutor Tneodore Roche and his as
sistant, Matt Sullivan, said that the
Jury would be completed by to-mor-
row’ evening. »
Interest in the Caminettl case ap
parently exceeds that shown in the
case of Diggs. A large crowd of
spectators was turned away from the
courtroom doors to-day. Prepara
tions were made by the marshal’s of
fice to cope with the enormous crowds
when Miss Warrington and Miss Nor
ris take the stand.
Rides 500 Miles to
Buy Col. Cody's Pet
Horse as Gift to Him
DENVER, Aug. 26—Friends of
Buffalo Bill outbid each other at the
auction sale of the Wild West show
property, when “Isham,” the famous
white horse ridden by Colonel Cody
at every performance for 25 years
was offered by the auctioneer.
The bidding was spirited and every
man was actuated by one sentiment
—presenting the faithful animal to
the veteran plainsman.
Col. J. C. Bills, of Lincoln. Neb.,
rode 500 miles in an auto to be pres
ent. He started the bidding.
There was general rejoicing when
the animal was knocked down to
Colonel Bills, who declare he would
present the animal to “Its rightful
owner. Colonel Cody.”
The Kaiser Becomes
A Total Abstainer
BERLIN. Aug. 26.—The Kaiser has
laid his embargo on neer. Kts favor
ite drink now Is lemonade, with a
dash of orange Juice, but does not
force this beverage upon his guests.
The usual wines are served.
The Kaiser, It Is said, did not use
any alcoholic beverage while on his
Northern cruise and became con
vinced that being a teetotaller gives
to him more energy. He believes im
moderate drinking is one of the great
est factors in retarding the develop
ment of nations.
DIES AS HE PRAYS.
DANVILLE, ILL.. Aug. 26— Anton
Schingel, aged 67, died in St. Joseph's
Catholic Church while kneeling hi
prayer.
Well, now that Atlanta has settled
back to business, what'a the matter
with your entering the Want Ad Con
test and winning an automobile, or
maybe a trip to California and back
for you and your wife? Or why not
enter your church, your lodge, your
club; get all the members interested,
form a committee, get busy and win
$1,000 in gold?
Somebody’s going to win these
prizes. Somebody's going to b# driv
ing a five-passenger automobile this
fall and bragging about how they got
it. Some organization is going to
have $1,000 to buiid an addition with
or to put in the treasury, and It
might as well be yours.
Lots of Them In.
Several churches, two or three se
cret orders and several other organi
zations already have entered, named
their committees and begun solicita
tion among their friends. Quite a
bunch of individual workers are in
the game, too, and they range all the
way from grown-ups to children
about knee high. The names of con
testants will be published in the near
future. There are prizes for every
body, every contestant has a chance,
and the contest is still just at Its be
ginning. so there’s a good opportuni
ty for you to get in and win out.
FOR NERVOUSNESS
Take Horsford’* Aeld Phosphate
nifhlv rerommended fur relief of Insomnia,
nervous headache, nausea and Impaired di
gestion. Adv.
f«V****«V*V»^Last Days of August Blanket and Bedding Sale, W«i*«««YJ *i»Y»Y*
M. RICH & BROS. CO
Gordele Cotton Men
Fight Tax Ordinance
CORDELE, Aug. 26.—If the threats
of local cotton buyers are carried out.
Cordele will practically be without a
cotton market for an entire week or ■
more.
The buyers are angered at the Cite '
Council over the passage of an ordi- |
nance making their annual license $25 j
and the license on transient buyers a*. |
$1 per day. On the grounds that the
officials had discriminated and that |
the license of local and transleni buy- ,
ers should be the same, the local cot
ton men requested the Council to re - >
consider its action, which was re- j
fused.
I Less Than 2 Score Short Hours Wind bp E
jThe August Furniture Saief
After That Prices Go Back to Normal--to Stay
3
i
Just three and a half shopping days—less
hours—mark the end of this sale
than two score shopping
dS
People know this is an opportunity that comes hut twice a year; that
it is in no sense comparable with the continuous performance reduction sales
which have wearied the patient and long-suffering public during the last six
months.
Belated customers, therefore, who come here Monday expecting to pick
up the “bargain” they saw Saturday or before, will be disappointed. At the
tap of the closing bell Saturday at 1 P. M., these remarkable savings
an end.
WAS IS
5?
s
I
1
come to Sz
CARLETON Y. SMITH. C. A. THORNTON. W. T. WINN
SMITH. THORNTON, WINN & CO.
INSURANCE
Phone 1685-6 Ivy.
Atlanta, Ga.
608-12 Walton Bldg.
SEMI-ANNUAL STATEMENT
For the six months ending June 30, 1913, of the condition of the
ATLANTA HUME INSURANCE COMPANY
OF ATLANTA,
Organized under the laws of the State of Georgia, made to the Governor
of the State of Georgia, in pursuance of the laws of said State. Principal
office—No. 223 Equitable Building.
I. CAPITAL STOCK.
Whole amount of capital stock
Amount paid up In cash SOO.ouO.uO
It. ASSETS.
Total assets of the company, actual cash market value ... $481,710.51
Green Striped Denim Library Chair $ 25.00
Tapestry Upholstered Wing Library Rocker .... 27.00
Green Striped Denim Library Chair 21.00
Solid Mahogany Tapestry Library Chair, pair
Solid Mahogany Tapestry Library Rocker, pair
Solid Mahogany Panne Plush Library Rocker .. 25.00
Imitation Mahogany Green Denim Library Rocker 25.00
2- piece Genuine Leather Library Suit 70.00
3- piece Genuine Leather Library Suit 9S.OO
Imitation Mahogany Genuine Leather Davenport 65.00
Quartered Oak Genuine Leather Davenport ....
3-piece Antique Tapestry Parlor Suit
Green Striped Denim Library Chair
Spanish Leather Library Arm Chair
Genuine Leather Library Rocker
Spanish Leather Library Rocker
Spanish Leather Library Arm Chair
3-piece Panne Plus Parlor Suit
Empire Sofa. Solid Mahogany Denim (soiled) ...
Solid Mahogany Antique Chair, cane seat and back 23.50
Jacobean Onk Settee, cane seat ami back ...... 55.00
Flanders Oak Chair, cane seat and back 18.50
1 English Wing Fireside Library Chair 35.00
} 60.00
55.00
92.00
25.00
40.00
39.00
45.00
39.00
125.00
85.00
$481,710.51
$ 52,018.47
OF THE
$ 48,480.07
ill. LIABILITIES.
Total liabilities
IV. INCOME DURING THE FIRST SIX MONTHS OF THE YEAR 1913.
Total income actually received during the first six months
in cash
V. EXPENDITURES DURING THE FIRST SIX MONTHS
YEAR 1913.
Total expenditures during the first six months of the year
in cash
Greatest amount insured in any one risk $ 25.000.00
Total amount of insurance outstanding 6,332,494.00
A copy of the act of incorporation, duly certified, is of file in the of
fice of the Insurance Commissioner.
STATE OF GEORGIA—County of Fulton.
Personally appeared before the undersigned notary public Charles
A. Bickerstaff, who, being duly sworn, deposes and says that he Is the
secretary of the Atlanta Home Insurance Company, and that the forego
ing statement is correct and true. CHARLES A. BICKERSTAFF.
Sworn to and subscribed before me this 23d day of July, 1913.
RAY WISDOM,
Notary Pnbilc, Fulton County, Georglal
Name of Agents at Atlanta -SMITH, THORNTON, WINN & CO.
1 Solid Mahogany Chippendale Library Chair,
‘Crotch Veneer, Panel Top 33.50
1 very massive 3-piece Antique Tapestry Parlor
Suit 92.00
1 3-plece Mahogany frame Panne Plush Parlor
Suit 125.00
1 dark green Genuine Leather 3-piece Library
or Parlor Suit 98.00
1 dark green Genuine Leather Settee and Arm
Chair to match 70.00
1 6-foot Golden Quartered Oak Genuine Leather
Davenport 55.00
1 6-foot dark green Leather Imitation Mahogany
Davenport 65.00
1 3-piece Solid Mahogany, Sheraton design, Par
lor Suit, beautiful tapestry cover 135.00
$307.50 Dining Room Suit $225.
A handsome production in Flanders Oak. One of the choicest
art (lining room suits developed by the Gram) Rapids crafts
men. Consists of 1 sideboard. 1 china cabinet, 1 serving table,
1 54-lnch dining table, 0 leather chairs. Suit complete, only
wM.
(Furniture—Fq^t* , Floor)
$13.50
15.00
12.50
30.00
15.00
12.50
35.00
50.00
25.00
25.00
45.00
12.50
20.00
15.00
22.50
15.00
60.00
50.00
10.00
25.00
10.00
25.00
20.00
45.00
60.00
50.00
35.00
25.00
25.00
75.00
Art & Crafts
Furniture
Standard patterns from one of
the three best makers in America.
Not the cheap “glue and ham
mer” Mission furniture, but gen
uine Arts and Crafts Fumed Oak,
with every joint doweled and
mortised with wood pin. Furni
ture of integrity to last for gen
erations. All finished with best,
grade genuine Spanish leather.
$12.50 Chair,
as shown, at
$12.50 Rocker
to match at
$25.00 Settee
to match at
$7.75
’ $7.75
$16.50
I A Bed Special
$10.00
$12.50
1 2
1 2
1 3-
1 2
1 2
WAS
-inch Post Brass Bed,, full size $18.50
-inch Post Satin Finish Brass Bed, full size 18.50
inch Post Satin Finish Brass Bed 35.00
-inch Post Bright Solid Brass Bed 40.00
-inch Square Post Single Brass Bed’ 40.00
IS
$12.50
12.50
25.00
25.00
20.00
£
5;
i
£
2 TRAINS DAILY
Lv,7;12AM.,5:i0m
50-lb Felt Mattress,
art tick, any color
«8 Guaranteed Box
‘S Spring to macth
Any furniture bought now
•« will be stored free until
October 15.
' “ Furniture bought the rest
■S of this month on charge
JE account not payable until
October.
M. RICK & BROS. CO. ftjm M. RICH & BROS. CO.
Important Notice to
Charge Customers
All charge purchases for rest of the month go on
September statement mailed October 1st. Profit by
the August Sales; Pay in October,