Newspaper Page Text
i
f
T11K ATLANTA (IKOKC.IAN AND NEWS.
E’S THE TIME CLOCK
PUZZLE IN FRANK TRIAL;
CUN YOU FIGURE IT OUT?
THE RIDDLE OF THE CLOCK
IN THE PHAGAN MYSTERY
Jim Conley swears Mary Phagan went up the stairs of the
National Pencil factory and was murdered before Monteen
Stover arrived. He says he saw Miss Stover go up and leave.
Monteen Stover, State’s witness, swears she arrived at
12:05.
George Epps, State’s witness, swears he and Mary Phagan
arrived at Marietta and Forsyth streets at 12:07.
The car crew, defense’s witnesses, swear Mary arrived at
Broad and Marietta at 12:07V2 and at Broad and Hunter at
12:10.
If Mary Phagan was at Marietta and Forsyth at 12:07, as
the State says, or at Broad and Hunter at 12:10, as the defense
says, how could she have preceded Monteen Stover, as Jim
Conley says, up the factory stairs, when Miss Stover was in the
factory at 12:05?
What’s the answer?
By JAMES B. NEVIN.
Tick-fork ! Tick-tock!
Hark to the tale of the old hall clock!
Tick-toek! Tick-tock!
This is the tale of the clock!
—Old English Ballad.
This is a tale of an office clock and
a motorman’s ^Vntch—an office clock
In the National Pencil Factory, the
first requisite of which, it being a
‘‘time” clock, is accuracy, and a mo
torman’s watch.
And thisi is the story of a clock that
may or may not mean life and liberty
rnd a restored good name to Leo
Frank, or—a fate infinitely worse
‘h "i mere death itself!
I ' n story involving: a vounp: busi-
r — man of repute and high stand-
li m college graduate and a husband,
a 1 rave, womanly little girl, foully
murdered, a motorman known to
mnnv '‘‘antans. a newsboy not so
well i a disinterested working
rrir! ’ ”-gro sweeper, a confe?med ac-
- ■ - • to murder, the dead girl’s
mo’ , r -and an office clock.
"" at does the story demonstrate 0
That shall be for the reader to say.
Here is the story:
What the State Contends.
The State of Georgia is contending
that Leo Frank murdered on April
26. before the hour of 12:OS In the
afternoon, Mary Phagan, a 14-year-
old working girl, employed In the Ra
tional Pencil Factory, of which Frank
was the superintendent.
It cites, among others, to bear out
its contention. James Conley, a negro
sweeper In the factory, and Monteen
Stover, an employee of the factory.
Miss Stover is a disinterested wit
ness—Conley not only is the star
witness against Frank, but is inter
ested in fixing the murder upon
Frank.
Here is what the State, by Its own
witnesses, asserts:
Jim Conley swears that a few min
utes before Miss Monteen Stover ci;ne
Into the factory—Miss Stover herself
Swearing that she entered at 12:05—
Mary Phagan entered and passed up
stairs and into Leo Frank’s office.
Miss Stover, asked how she was
positive as to the time she went in
and the time she came out, stated
that she looked at the time clock both
ns she came In and as she went out.
That fixes the time of her coming
and going definitely and exactly.
It was before Miss Stover came in
that Conley swears Mary Phagah
came in. Therefore, Mary Phagan
must have arrived at the factory, ac-
rordlng to Conley, at least before
12:05, the moment Miss Stover came
in.
Before Miss Stover Entered.
But after Mary came in, and before
Miss Stover came in, the murder,
still according to Conley, had been
effected.
For (a) after Mary went upstairs
and before Mins Stover came in, Con
ley (b) heard pattering footsteps
toward the rear of the building, where
(c) he says the body was found by
him later, and after that (d) a
scream, and then (e) a period of
silence.
All of this, according to Conley, be
fore Monteen Stover entered the fac
tory—that is, before 12:05 certainly—
and, considering the things Conley
swears happened, several minutes be
fore 12:05, necessarily.
Mrs. Coleman, Mary’s mother,
swears that Mary left home “about
11:45” in the morning, and George
Epps swears he joined her on the car
at 11:50, for he looked at a clock at
home Just before boarding the car.
and that he and Marv arrived at
Marietta and Forsyth streets at 12:07,
the latter hour not definitely fixed in
his mind.
Motorman Remembers Time.
The motorman on that car. how'-
ever, who swears he knew Mary Pha
gan, and had seen her board his car
frequently, and remembers seeing her
board that particular car on that par
ticular day, says that the car arrived
at Marietta and Forsyth at 12: 7^. as
that is the time it is scheduled to ar
rive there, and he was running on
time that day.
The motorman swears Mary and a
companion got off at Hunter and
Broad about 12:10, that being a few
minutes’ farther run than Marietta
and Forsyth. The conductor corrob
orates the motorman in an additional
statement that the car was not run
ning ahead of schedule, the conduc
tors being particularly required by
the company not to run ahead of
time.
Mary Phagan left the street car at
12:10, still a block and a half from
the pencil factory.
If she walked directly to the fac
tory, she could not have reached
there before 12:12, in any event.
If the little victim of this tragedy,
Mary Phagan. therefore, DID NOT
REACH THE FACTORY UNTIL
MANY MINUTES AFTER CONLEY
SWEARS SHE DID GET THERE.
AND UNTIL AT LEAST TWO MIN
UTES AFTER MONTEEN STOVER
HAD DEPARTED, AND UNTIL
AFTER CONLEY SWEARS HE HAD
HEARD THE FOOTSTEPS AND
THE SCREAM. HOW CAN CON
LEY’S STORY BE TRUE?
Slain Before She Arrived?
In other words, how could Mary
Phagan have been murdered before
she arrived at the factory?
Remember, too, that when Frank
was asked at the Coroner’s inquest as
to the time of Mary Phagan’s arrival,
he said that it was after 12, because
the noon whistle had blown some time
before—that she might have arrived
at 12:10 or. maybe later, perhaps as
late as 12:20 or 12:25.
Conley, also, in fixing the time of
Mary Phagan’s arrival at the factory,
said it was soon after the noon whis
tle blew, therefore, a little after 12
—thus placing Mary's arrival between
12 and the time of Monteen Stover’s
arrival, which was 12:05.
Now then, take your pencil and
paper, and figure this problem out for
yourself.
Can you reconcile Conley’s story
with the other things proved, in the
main, by the State’s own witnesses?
Poteat Suggests Jail
For Slit Skirt Girls
NEW HAVEN. CONN., Aug. 9.—
President Edwin Poteat, of Furman
College, Greenville, 6. C., says young
women who are parading in New Ha
ven with slit skirts should be put in
ia.il.
“Women who indulge in such de
praved dress are a menace morally to
the commonwealth,” said Poteat.
65,000,000 Pounds
Of Butter On Ice
CHICAGO. Aug. 9.—Although Chi
cago housewives have been paying
mid-Vinter prices for butter and a
further advance is expected, there are
more than 65.000,000 pounds in cold
storage, according to the Warehouse
men's Association. This is 10,000,000
more than the reserve a year ago.
Two Girls to Accuse
Diggs and Caminetti
SAN FRANCISCO, Aug. 9.—Marsha
Warrington and Ida Norris, the Sac
ramento high school girls alleged to
have been taken to Reno in November
by Maury I. Diggs and Drew Caminetti
for immoral purposes, will take the
stand against Diggs when his trial i3
resumed Tuesday. No session of the
Diggs trial was held to-day. Diggs
and Caminetti will take the stand be
fore the trial is concluded.
Judge Van Fleet dealt the defense
another hard biow yesterday when he
announced that the jury would not con
sider the willingness or unwillingness of
** two girls to accompany Diggs and
Caminetti.
HOW TIME HAS BECOME THE CRUCIAL
POINT IN THE TRIAL OF LEO M. FRANK
> Mary leaves car at 12:07 by State’s testimony and 12:10 by
I witnesses for the defense.
Mary boards the Coop
er street car at 11:50,
according to wit
nesses for
both State
and de
fense.
Monteen Stover enters
factory at 12:05 and
SPOILS ME OF GOOD
DAY FOR THE DEFENSE
Mary
Phagan
leaves her
home at 11:45,
according to her mother
Absence of Alienists and
The Hypothetical Question
Distinguishes Frank Trial
By O. B. KEELER.
HAZELHURST HOME BURNS.
HAZELHTTRST.—The residence of
R. T. Williams burned this morning
at 2 o’clock, the family barely escap
ing. The loss is $3,800 with $1,500
insurance. Tne fire originated about
the kitchen,
There are tw*o things about the
Frank trial that entitle It to dis
tinguished consideration.
Thus far not a single alienist has
been called to bat, and only the com
mon or domesticated type of the
dread Hypothetical Question has ap
peared.
In most of our great murder trials,
the alienist is th e last resort, or one
of the latest resorts. Usually he is in
troduced by the defense; anywhere
from four to eight of him.
The prosecution promptly counters
with an equal number of wheel in
spectors.
The defense (vide Thaw case) gen
erally proves to its own satisfaction
that the defendant was crazy when
he did it, but since has recovered his
equilibrium, his alibi and all the rest
of his scattered personal effects.
The four to eight experts for the
State differ slightly with this find
ing.
They All Agree.
They report that to the best of
their several and collective knowl
edge and belief, which is consider
able, the defendant is the happy pos
sessor of one of the sanest little noo
dles they ever had the pleasure of
sitting on. They say there is prac
tically no chance that any such care
fully-geared aggregation of mental
sprockets ever slipped a cog.
But they add that, if the defense
insists on the accused having been
non compos at the time he did it, he
most assuredly is in the same condi
tion at present, or more so.
In short, the State contends that
the defendant either should be hang
ed or remanded to the solitary uphol
stery for the rest of his life, accord
ing to which is most highly objec
tionable to the defense.
Vide Thaw case ad lib.
One Notable Exception.
Ther© Is only one case on record
where a corps of alienists employed
by one side agreed with those hired
by the opposition.
It seems that the accused person,
j without any advice or suggestion from
his lawyers, broke out all over with
shockingly acute symptoms of demen
tia soon after he was arrested.
The defense ordered out the alien
ists.
They reported that the accused un
questionably was insane—remarkably
insane.
Then the prosecution recruited its
experts to the full war strength ani
ordered them to advance with cau
tion.
To the intense surprise of everyone,
includins the defense, they reported
that the prisoner was crazy beyond
the shadow of a peradventure. They
said he couldn’t be any crazier with
out coming apart.
Well, that just about settled it.
What prosecution could hold out
against the rombined forces of two
sets of alienists? It was the first
time on record that the w'arring ex
perts had agreed.
And this time they were both
wrong.
Inside of a year the record-holder
for craziness—sprints, middle dU-
j tanc* and Marathon—had got himself
out of the bat factory and war en
joying life in a more congenial ime
that had no extradition provisions in
the treaty, if any.
The Hypothetical Question.
The hypothetical question is used
rather more frequently than the alien
ist. because it is less expensive and
embarrarssing, while offering no more
than an even break to the other side
and confusing the jury fully as muon
as the most complicated alienist!** j
explosions.
When the h. q. is sprung bv the
defense, an expert of considerable
pedigree is propped up in the wit
ness chair and compelled to listen,
with the jury and such of the auditors
as can stay awake, to a detailed rela
tion of incidents beginning some time
before the birth of the accused and
extending to the date of the crim \
with provisions and qualifications to
fill out four hours and a half and
eleven columns of “six point.”
Then the expert says:
"No.”
After which an expert for the other
side listens to the same recital, re
peated.
And he says:
“Yes.”
What the Jury says never gets into
print.
DIXIE COLLEGES
Report of Miss Elizabeth Avery
Coulton Shows 160 With High
Entrance Requirements.
French Tars Flee in Panic.
L’ORIENT, FRANCE, Aug. 9.—
Twenty sailors on board the French
battleship Courbet were scalded and
otherwise injured to-day when a tank
exploded on the ship. Thinking that
the magazine had let go the crew
rushed on the decks in a panic and
many leaped overboard.
WASHINGTON, Aug. 9.—A record
of great improvement in Southern
colleges is contained in a report by
Miss Elizabeth Avery Coulton, sec
retary of the Southern Association of
College Women, which is being dis
tributed by the United States Bureau
of Education.
In 1900 only three Southern col
leges had standard requirements for
entrance; this year year 160 an
nounced standard admission require
ments. The improvement is found
also in libraries, laboratories, build
ings and equipment of all kinds. In
1904 the A. B. of only tw r o Southern
colleges represented four full years
of college work, while by 1914 grad
uates of at least 25 colleges will have
completed four years of standard col
lege work.
Miss Coulton attributes the ad
vance chiefly to two agencies—the
Carnegie Foundation for the Ad
vancement of Teaching and the Gen
eral Education Board.
Much still remains to be done,
however, according to Miss Coulton.
“There remains the hope,” she says,
"that many sham colleges may wdth
in the next ten or twelve years be in
duced to stop conferring degrees and
become good preparatory or indus
trial schools; that others may die from
lack of patronage, and tn*t the ‘right
eous remnant’ may thus be encour
aged to continue to strive after ever
enlarging ideals of standard and of
service.”
Brand Whitlock May
Get Diplomatic Post
WASHINGTON. Aug. 9.—President
Wilson is seriously considering the
nomination of another distinguished
author to an Important diplomatic
post, according to information at the
Capitol. Mayor Brand Whitlock of
Toledo, Ohio, is the latest prospective
candidate for diplomatic honors, ani
if McCombs declines the French am-'
bassadorship, he may get that, or he
may go to Belgium.
He had expressed a desire for the
Switzerland mission, but that whs
promised before he got into the fight.
heard her scream
BEFORE Monteen Sto
ver came.
ATLANTA GIRL IS
Ethel Edmondson Overwhelmed
by Wrightsville Breakers—At
tempted Rescue Fails.
Miss Ethel Edmondson, 24, daugh
ter of Mrs. S. P. Fincher, of No. 343
North Jackson street, was drowned at
Wrightsville Beach Friday afternoon.
She had been at the beach but a few
hours* when she decided to enter the
surf. Scarcely had she reached the
water when a huge wave raced in and
knocked her down.
Roy Walraven, of Atlanta, who was
wtth Miss Edmondson, was stunned
for a moment by the force of the
wave, but recovered quickly and went
to her rescue. He had a terrific strug
gle and but for the timely arrival
of Life Saver W. E. Watson he prob
ably would have lost his life.
Miss Edmondson left Atlanta on
Thumlay night with a party of seven
for a ten-day stay at the beach.
She was a member of Grace Meth
odist Church and was employed as a
stenographer by the Wester Music
Company.
News of her daughter’s sudden
death almost prostrated Mrs. Fincher.
The body is expected to arrive in At-
ltnata to-day. Funeral arrangements
will he announced later.
Slezak Is Rescued;
Sturmfeld Drowns.
Special Cable to The Atlanta Georgian.
TEGERNSEE, BAVARIA, Aug. 9.—
A yacht in which Fritz Sturmfeld and
Leo Slezak, the operatic tenors, were
sailing on the lake here, overturned
and Sturmfeld was drowned. Slezak
clung to the boat and was rescued.
Sturmfeld was a member of the
Royal Opera at Liepzic. He made a
concert tour in the United States in
1911. Slezak is well known in the
United States, having sung at the
Metropolitan Opera House in New
York.
Titanic Lookout Who
Missed Iceberg Dies
Special Cable to The Atlanta Georgian.
LONDON, Aug. 9.—Reginald Lee.
one of the sailors In the lookout when
the White Star Liner Titanic struck
an iceberg on April 14, last year,
died at Southampton,
What promised to he a v.ery favor
able day for the defense in the trial
of Loo M Frank, charged with the
murder of Mary Phagan, was partly
sp >iled at its close Friday by the'be
wilderment of E. F. Holloway, day
watchman at the pencil factory, in a
maze of conflicting statements.
Holloway’s confusion under the fire
of the Solicitor General was more
than offset by the Importance of the
testimony which had gone before,
two of the witnesses* giving testimony
which was intended to establish that
Mary Phagan did not enter the Na
tional Pencil Factory on the day of
her death until after Monteen Stover
had come and gone.
Besides giving the He direct to Jim
Conley’s tale, this testimony, if it
stands as the truth in the minds of
the Jurors, upsets the State’s theory
that Monteen Stover visited the office
of Leo Frank while the superintend
ent was in the metal room with the
Phagan girl.
Conley said on the stand that ho
saw Lemmie Quinn, then Mary Pha
gan and then Mon teen Stover go up
to the second floor. The Stover girl
said that she entered the factory at
12:05 o’clock. It was 12:10 when she
left, she testified. She looked at the
time clock both times.
Street Car Men Testify.
W. M. Matthews arid W. T. Hollis,
the motorman and conductor on the
car which brought Mary into town the
day that she met her death, testified
that she did not leave the car befor?
12:10 o’clock, the Inference from this
testimony being that she could not
have entered the factory before Mon-
teen Stover and entered and left.
If the testimony of George Epps
the State’s witness, is accepted, the
defense declares Mary Phagan could
not have entered the plant before
Monteen Stover.
Matthews said that he knew' the
girl by sight and frequently spoke to
her when she boarded his car. He
said that he was relieved at Broad
and Marietta streets at 12:07 o’clock
the day of the crime and that h* 3
went inside the car and sat back
of Mary Phagan and a girl compan
ion while they were riding to Broad
and Hunter streets. He said they
got off at about 12:10 and walked to
ward the pencil factory.
Matthew’s’ story contradicts that of
George Epps, who testified on the
stand that he rode to town with
Mary, got ofT the car with her at
Forsyth and Marietta streets and
walked as far ns the viaduct with her
on her way to the pencil factory.
Matthews and Hollis’ both said that
they had no recollection of Epps be
ing on the car. Hollis said that Mary
was sitting alone when he took her
fare just after the car got onto Eng
lish avenue. Matthews said another
young girl was sitting with her when
the center of town was reached.
Attacks Conley's Story.
The significance of the story of the
two street car men !* that it seems
to add another falsehood to the many
that Jim Conley already has told and
freely admitted telling.
He did not see Mary Phagan go up
stairs to Frank’s office, hear the
sounds of footsteps going to the metal
room, then a girl’s scream, and after
this witness the entrance and depar
ture of Monteen Stover. On the con
trary, the Stover girl was in the fac
tory and gone before Mary Phagan
came inside the doors.
Holloway, the day w-atchman, was
called back to the stand by the de
fense to testify in rebuttal of Con
ley’s testimony in regard to the al
leged visits of women to Frank’s of
fice. Hollow'ay said that no Incidents
of this sort ever took place. Coni §y
would have had no opportunity of
watching at the door without his
(Holloway’s) knowing it. he declared.
He denied »hat Daisy Hopkins ever
visited the factory with a man while
he was on duty or that immorality of
any sort was practiced in the build
ing to his knowledge. He said that
Herbert Schiff and Frank were gener
ally In the office together on Satur
days and that neither of them ever
had women in the office.
Solicitor Dorsey began cross-exam
ining Holloway in savage fashion and
soon had the watchman badly rattled.
At one time Holloway refused to com
mit himself as to whst*he had testi
fied only a moment before.
“Was that negro drayman there
Saturday—you said so awhile ago.
didn’t you?” asked the Solicitor.
Holloway floundered w’hile Dorsey
was insisting on an answer. He
could not remember w hat he had tes
tified. Finally he blurted out:
“If I said be was there, he w’as.
If I said he wasn’t there, he wasn’t,”
Refers to Reward Claim.
"But what is the truth?” persisted
Dorsey.
Holloway continued to return the
same answer until Judge Roan forced
him to make a definite reply. Then
he took refuge in the old reliable an
swer: “I don’t remember.”
The Solicitor called Holloway's at
tention to a remark that the watchman
w as said to have made- about Conley
being “my nigger” when a reference
was made to the rewards offered. Ho
also showed an affidavit signed by
Holloway saying that Dnriev had left
the factory the Saturday of the killing
at 10:45 in the forenoon. Darley had
testified that he left at about 9:30
and Hollow’ay had said only a few
minutes before that Darley left about
9:20 or 9:30.
“What did you say 10:46 for in the
affidavit you signed for me shortly
after th e murder?" shouted the So
licitor.
“That was mostly guesswork,” ex
plained the witness.
“Did you tell Mr. Arnold that you
left the factory every day about 5:30
o’clock?”
"Yes.”
Said 3, but Meant 4 o*Clook.
“Didn’t you tell me that you left
sometimes at 3 o’clock?”
‘‘If 1 said 3. I meant 4."
"What did you mean by 4:30 just
now ?"
“That just slipped out.”
N. V. Darley, general manager of
the factory; H. J. Hinchey, of No. 391
Peachtree street; Harry Scott,
“Rbots” Rogers, I U. Kauffman, T. H.
Willett and J. Q. Adams were the
other witnesses of the day.
Kauffman identified blueprints and
drawings he had made of the Selig
home and of the pencil factory. Wil
lett explained the pasteboard model
of the factory that he had made from
the blueprints. Adams identified
photographs he had made at the Se-
lig home and the factory.
Hinchey told of seeing Frank com
ing from home on a Washington
street car the afternoon of the crime.
This was intended to discredit Al
bert McKnight, one of the State’s
witnesses, who said that he saw'
Frank board a Georgia avenue oar
when he left home.
Dftrley was recalled largely to tes
tify to the possibility of various
methods which Conley might have
employed In disposing of the girl’s
body in the event he was the mur
derer of the girl.
New Theory Is Suggested.
The most startling sugestion came
from Dnrley's testimony that a door
leading from the entryway on tha
first floor into the rear of the build
ing was found broken open right
after the crime. Two trap doors open
into the basement from this rear
room. One of them is over a chute.
Reuben Arnold, bv his line of ques
tioning, showed that the defense se
riously hnd considered the theiry that
the girl’s murderer had dragged her
through this door on the first floor
and had dropped her body down ihe
chute.
The Solicitor brought out that the
door might have been opened by the
detectives in their search of the
building and that if the body ever
had been dropped down the chute it
most probably would have been left
there, as it would have been perfectly
hidden.
Do You Know
Where io Buy
These Things
Magnifying Glasses,
Linen Testers,
Microscopes,
Goggles,
Stereoscopes,
Compasses,
Telescopes,
Field Glasses,
Binoculars,
Pedometers,
Eye Shades,
Opera Glasses,
Automatic Eyeglass Hold
ers,
Shell Library Frames,
Thermometers,
Barometers.
We carry a complete line of the
above, including special shapes
| and tinted goggles and other
j new and novel optical sundries.
Step in and look them over.
A. K. HAWKES CO.
OPTICIANS
14 WHITEHALL
ETROIT
2 TRAINS DAILY
Lvi/;l2AM,54flm